In this insightful conversation, Professor Kate Masur, an award-winning historian and expert on the 14th Amendment, joins the hosts to discuss the legality of Trump’s executive order on birthright citizenship. She provides historical context, debunking modern misconceptions and emphasizing the foundational role of citizenship in U.S. law. The discussion also touches on SCOTUS cases, the implications of recent executive actions, and the importance of understanding the historical roots of citizenship rights.
01:21:24
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Birthright Citizenship Debate
Trump's executive order on birthright citizenship is deemed illegal and challenged.
Some law professors argue, based on originalism, that the order might be constitutional.
insights INSIGHT
Podcast Episode Overview
The hosts plan to discuss the illegality of Trump's birthright citizenship executive order.
They will also cover Supreme Court cases and the Fifth Circuit's actions.
insights INSIGHT
14th Amendment and Citizenship
The 14th Amendment's citizenship clause is discussed in relation to Trump's executive order.
The Lincoln administration's view on citizenship, based on allegiance and protection, is examined.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
In 'Lawless: The Miseducation of America’s Elites,' Ilya Shapiro examines the transformation of higher education and legal education in the United States. He argues that prestigious law schools have been overtaken by radical student movements and biased faculty, leading to a decline in critical thinking, logical argumentation, and respect for opposing views. Shapiro draws from his personal experiences, including a controversial tweet that led to calls for his firing from Georgetown Law, to illustrate the institutional weaknesses and ideological capture of America’s law schools. The book warns that this trend has significant implications for the future of the legal profession, government, and society as a whole.
Until Justice Be Done
Kate Masur
Kate Masur's book, *Until Justice Be Done*, provides a comprehensive history of the first civil rights movement in the United States. It explores how Black and White Americans worked together to challenge racist laws and institutions from the Revolution through the 1870s. The book highlights the struggles faced by free Black people in Northern states and the efforts of activists to achieve legal equality, laying groundwork for future civil rights movements.
Freedom Was in Sight
Kate Masur
Elizabeth Clarke
This graphic history, written by Kate Masur and illustrated by Liz Clarke, offers a compelling narrative of Reconstruction in the Washington, D.C., area. It highlights the struggles and achievements of Black communities during this period, focusing on the creation of institutions and the fight for freedom. The book is praised for its accessible storytelling and powerful visuals, making it suitable for both educational settings and personal reading.
Melissa, Leah, and Kate are joined by Professor Kate Masur of Northwestern to talk about just how illegal and off-the-wall Trump’s executive order on birthright citizenship is. Then, the hosts cover the multitude of other horrors coming out of the executive branch, preview February’s SCOTUS cases, touch base with the wackos at the Fifth Circuit, and ask the all-important question: are the mens okay?
Get tickets for STRICT SCRUTINY LIVE – The Bad Decisions Tour 2025!