Introducing 'Power Play': How to win a TV election debate
Aug 30, 2024
auto_awesome
Brett O'Donnell, a seasoned debate coach for notable figures like Ron DeSantis and Boris Johnson, shares insider strategies for winning the upcoming Trump-Harris debate. The discussion delves into the dynamics of debate formats, highlighting how candidates can navigate messaging and performance issues. O'Donnell emphasizes the importance of public perception and historical context. They also explore the evolving confidence of female candidates, particularly in addressing controversial topics like abortion, and the challenge of staying authentic while delivering strategic responses.
Brett O'Donnell emphasized the importance of strategic civility and focus in debates, particularly under the muted microphone format.
The podcast highlighted the unique pressures female candidates face, suggesting Harris needs to manage her tone and delivery effectively.
Deep dives
Upcoming Presidential Debate Dynamics
The upcoming debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris is set to be a significant moment in the 2024 presidential race, with both candidates aiming to gain a tactical advantage. Discussions around debate rules, particularly the muted microphone rule, have become a point of contention between the two campaigns. Trump’s campaign believes this rule benefits them by allowing for more structured communication, while Harris's team is focused on creating an environment where she can effectively engage with Trump without being overshadowed. The outcome of this debate could hinge on whether both candidates can effectively navigate these dynamics and present compelling arguments.
Brett O'Donnell's Debate Coaching Insights
Brett O'Donnell, a seasoned debate coach, shared valuable strategies for preparing candidates for high-stakes debates. He emphasized the importance of maintaining civility and focus during the debate, highlighting how the muted microphone format could help achieve that. O'Donnell suggested that Harris should aim to provoke Trump during the debate to throw him off his game, while also presenting a vision for her presidency that contrasts effectively with Trump's record. He believes that debates are not just about confrontation but are critical messaging opportunities that can significantly influence public perception.
Navigating the Challenges of Female Politicians
The podcast delves into the unique challenges faced by female politicians during debates, particularly regarding public perception and scrutiny. Female candidates often receive more criticism for their delivery and demeanor, which can lead to increased pressure to perform flawlessly. O'Donnell provided coaching tips for Harris, advising her to manage her tone and maintain a steadiness in delivery, as these factors often contribute to the evaluation of their performances. The discussion highlights the need for female candidates to build confidence while also being mindful of the external judgments they face.
The Stakes of Remaining On-Message
Maintaining focus on core issues is crucial for both candidates, especially for Trump as he heads into the debate. Trump's ability to adhere to a policy-driven message will be key to countering criticism and highlighting Harris's controversial positions from her previous presidential campaign. The podcast emphasizes the challenge he faces with his natural tendency to veer off-topic, which could detract from serious discussions. Both campaigns need to ensure their candidates can engage in substantive debate without succumbing to personal attacks that might alienate key voter demographics.
A special bonus episode from Deep Dive's POLITICO sister podcast, Power Play:
With the U.S. presidential debate now confirmed, our Power Play guests explain the tips and tricks that could help Donald Trump or Kamala Harris win their first head-to-head encounter on Sept. 10 — and why there has been a pre-debate row over format and mics.
POLITICO’s Anne McElvoy is joined by Brett O’Donnell, a veteran expert on preparing candidates for debate on both sides of the pond, having coached Republicans Ron DeSantis, Mitt Romney, John McCain and George W. Bush, as well as prepping Rishi Sunak and Boris Johnson for their televised tussles in the U.K.
Then POLITICO’s Rachael Bade, co-author of our Playbook in Washington, reveals which way the political winds are blowing, following last week’s momentous Democratic National Convention and how the rival Trump-Harris campaigns are preparing for the forthcoming debate.