Jonathan Metzl, a Professor of Sociology and Psychiatry at Vanderbilt University, discusses the flaws in our gun-control strategy and how we talk about gun owners. The podcast also explores the New York election and the association of gun rights with patriotism. The fading national conversation on mass shootings is examined, highlighting the importance of understanding the before and after of such incidents.
The leniency of open carry laws raises questions about the public health approach to gun violence and the need for alternative solutions.
Understanding the motivations and perspectives of gun owners is crucial in bridging the gap between differing ideologies and effectively addressing gun violence.
Deep dives
The confusing mayoral race in Long Island and Queens
In a mayoral race in Long Island and Queens, there is confusion around the candidates and their positions. Tom Swazie, a Democrat, is the mayor of Glen Cove and a former congressman, while Republican Mazzy Pilop is his opponent. Pilop, an Ethiopian Jew raised in Israel, has a mysterious background. Voters are uncertain about her political stance on issues like abortion and are skeptical about her commitment to funding for Israel and Ukraine. The race has received limited media coverage, particularly from local television networks, due to being in a large media market.
The impact of open carry laws on gun ownership
The case of Travis Reinking, who carried out a mass shooting in Nashville, brings attention to the impact of open carry laws on gun ownership. Reinking, who had exhibited concerning behavior in Illinois, moved to Tennessee where open carry laws allowed him to possess guns without restrictions. The leniency of these laws and the lack of intervention before the shooting raises questions about the public health approach to gun violence. Traditional public health measures focused on reducing injuries and deaths may not be effective in convincing red state gun owners about the need for stricter regulations.
Rethinking gun control beyond legislation
Jonathan Metzel's book analyzes the complexities of gun culture and the limitations of public health strategies in addressing gun violence. He suggests considering alternative solutions that enlist private industry and incentivize gun safety to create a safer society. Rethinking the terms of the debate and engaging in structural interventions focused on community-based approaches rather than purely legislative measures could help prevent gun-related incidents. Metzel emphasizes the need to understand the motivations and perspectives of gun owners, particularly in red states, to bridge the gap between differing ideologies and effectively address the issue.
The optimism of 'Walking in a Winter Wonderland'
'Walking in a Winter Wonderland' provides a cheerful and optimistic perspective on wintry weather, contrasting with modern attitudes of climate doom. The song's joyful melody and lyrics evoke a sense of wonderment and appreciation for the beauty of snowy landscapes. In today's climate debate, where every weather event is often attributed to climate change, the song's lightheartedness may seem out of place. However, the song serves as a reminder to embrace the present moment and find joy in the simple pleasures, even amidst concerns about the environment and weather patterns.
Jonathan Metzl, Professor of Sociology and Psychiatry at Vanderbilt University and author of What We've Become: Living and Dying in a Country of Arms on examining the flaws in our gun-control strategy and how we talk about gun owners. Plus, the race to replace George Santos comes down to snow. And would a "Winter Wonderland" occur to any songwriter today?