Caroline West, author of "Wrong Women: Selling Sex in Monto, Dublin's Forgotten Red Light District," shares insights on Dublin's Monto, Europe's largest red light district from 1860 to 1925. She discusses the challenges and resilience of sex workers, their tight-knit community amid hardship, and their surprising influence on fashion trends. The conversation highlights the complex morality surrounding sex work and the historical stigma faced by women labeled as 'fallen,' while emphasizing ongoing battles for recognition and rights in today's society.
Dublin's Monto district, thriving between 1860 and 1925, became a crucial refuge for women escaping poverty and violence.
The Contagious Diseases Act marked a significant turning point, subjecting sex workers to invasive procedures under the guise of public health.
Despite societal stigma and systemic exploitation, women in Monto fostered a resilient community that provided mutual support and agency.
Deep dives
Dublin's Red-Light District
Dublin's Monto district served as a significant red-light area between 1860 and 1925, housing up to 1,600 sex workers at any given time. This small area, characterized by dense tenement housing and a network of narrow alleyways, became a refuge for countless women seeking escape from dire circumstances. Proximity to military barracks and docks made Monto an ideal location for a bustling sex trade, attracting soldiers, sailors, and other patrons. The stories woven into this district reveal a rich tapestry of survival amidst societal stigma and hardship.
Historical Context of Sex Work in Monto
The history of the Monto district is tied closely to issues of poverty and the aftermath of the Great Famine in Ireland, which led many women to sex work as a means of survival. Many women found themselves in Monto due to family violence, economic hardship, or limited opportunities for respectable work. Against a backdrop of increasing Catholic Church influence, sex work became stigmatized, with the women often treated as 'fallen' or 'unfortunate.' This societal shame compounded their struggles, often leaving them with few avenues for escape.
The Impact of the Contagious Diseases Act
The Contagious Diseases Act represented a key turning point in the treatment of sex workers during this era, focusing on controlling sexually transmitted diseases while disproportionately targeting women. Under this act, many women faced invasive examinations and medical procedures that were often violent and humiliating. The underlying motivation was not public health but rather the maintenance of military readiness, revealing a stark indifference to the well-being of the women affected. This institutional violence and disregard contributed to ongoing cycles of trauma among sex workers.
Agency and Community Among Sex Workers
Despite facing systemic challenges, women in Monto developed a sense of community and agency that allowed them to navigate their harsh circumstances. Many sex workers banded together, sharing resources, providing mutual support, and even pooling finances to protect themselves from exploitation. The madams played pivotal roles in managing the brothels while also occasionally offering shelter and assistance to those in need. This sense of solidarity not only highlighted the resilience of the women but also reflected their capacity to carve out lives in an unforgiving environment.
End of Monto and Continuing Struggles
Monto was officially closed in 1925 through the efforts of religious activists, who aimed to eradicate the district and impose a moral order. However, this closure did not reduce the need for sex work; rather, it displaced it, causing many women to seek work in less visible, and often more dangerous, circumstances. Policymaking surrounding sex work remained disconnected from the needs and realities of the women involved, perpetuating cycles of violence and marginalization. The struggles faced by sex workers continue to resonate today, with calls for a more nuanced understanding and respectful treatment of those involved in the sex trade.
Between 1860 and 1925, tens of thousands of women worked in Dublin's Monto, the largest red light district in Europe.
It was a world of narrow alleyways full of brothels busy with sex workers, at a time when the Catholic church was trying to establish ideas around what a woman should be. Hint: it was very different to the women of Monto.
What was life like for the women who lived and worked in Monto? How did these 'poor unfortunates', as they were known, create a community and support each other amidst such hard times? And how did they influence fashion trends of the time?
This episode was edited by Tom Delargy and produced by Stuart Beckwith. The senior producer was Charlotte Long.
If you'd like to get in touch with the show you can contact us at betwixt@historyhit.com.
Sign up to History Hit for hundreds of hours of original documentaries, with a new release every week and ad-free podcasts. Sign up at https://www.historyhit.com/subscribe.