Beyond Marx: A Modern Vision for Economic Democracy, Labor Contracts, and Employee-Owned Cooperatives | David Ellerman
Jul 2, 2024
auto_awesome
David Ellerman, a distinguished economist and philosopher, discusses the flaws of Marxist and traditional economic theories. He explores the historical context of labor contracts, the psychological cost of layoffs, and the evolution of ESOPs. The conversation delves into the link between performance management systems and American slavery, the role of economic theories in shaping organizational practices, and real-world examples of democratic firms and worker cooperatives.
State ownership rather than worker cooperatives resulted from Marxist revolutions, challenging the concept of empowering workers.
Labor contracts involve alienation of rights, emphasizing the distinction between alienable and inalienable rights and the importance of individual responsibility.
Worker cooperatives like Mondragon exemplify democratic firms, redefining the nature of work by viewing it as a product employees 'buy' with their labor for intrinsic value and fulfillment.
Deep dives
Reevaluating the Socialist Revolution and Worker Cooperatives
Marxist revolutions historically led to state ownership rather than worker cooperatives. This challenges the concept of socialist revolutions seeking to empower workers. State ownership dominated these revolutions, even in cases like Yugoslavia. The discussion questions the notion of economic democracy tied to Marxist ideals like the dictatorship of the proletariat.
Rethinking Labor Contracts and Inalienable Rights
Labor contracts typically involve the alienation of rights, where employees yield control to employers. The distinction between alienable and inalienable rights is crucial. Inalienable rights, like personal responsibility, remain with individuals even under contract. This challenges notions of alienation in employment terms and emphasizes the critical role of individual responsibility in work environments.
Challenging Traditional Economic Theories
The critique extends to traditional economic theories and Marx's economic perspectives. The focus is on the misconception of private ownership of the means of production as the defining factor in economic systems. Examples like Studebaker Packard's manufacturing setup with Chrysler owning the means of production but Studebaker controlling operations illustrate the complexity of ownership dynamics.
Empowering Workers Through Democratic Firms
Worker cooperatives like Mondragon in Spain exemplify democratic firm structures where employees are also owners. This approach contrasts with conventional corporations and highlights the importance of ownership rights tied to patronage. By delegating management power to employees and establishing ownership through working ties, democratic firms redefine the traditional labor contract.
Shifting Perspectives on Work and Ownership Models
The discussion transcends mere ownership dynamics to redefine the nature of work itself. Viewing work as a product employees 'buy' with their labor emphasizes the intrinsic value and experiences work provides. This perspective challenges traditional economic structures and emphasizes the importance of aligning work experiences with individual motivations and fulfillment.
Despite their revolutionary zeal, followers of Marx have failed to create real economic democracies, frequently ending up with one-party systems that mirror the capitalist structures they sought to overthrow. A compelling alternative exists: a modern vision for economic democracy and employee-owned cooperatives. By examining the historical missteps and unveiling innovative approaches, we discover how true democratic firms can thrive today.
David Ellerman is a distinguished economist, philosopher, and author with a career focused on the crossroads of economics, philosophy, and organizational theory. He has held prominent roles, such as an economic advisor at the World Bank, where he played a key role in shaping development policy and institutional reforms. Before his time at the World Bank, David was a visiting scholar at the University of California, Riverside, and lectured at Boston University.
In this episode, Dart and David discuss: - The historical context of labor contracts and alienation - Differences between alienable and inalienable rights - The link between performance management systems and American slavery - The flawed basis of Marxist and traditional economic theories - Real-world examples of democratic firms and worker cooperatives - The evolution and impact of ESOPs (Employee Stock Ownership Plans) - The psychological cost of layoffs in an organization - The role of economic theories in shaping organizational practices - And other topics…
David Ellerman is a renowned economist, philosopher, and author who has dedicated his career to exploring the intersections of economics, philosophy, and organizational theory. David has held influential positions, including serving as an economic advisor at the World Bank, where he contributed to development policy and institutional reforms. Prior to his tenure at the World Bank, he also served as a visiting scholar at the University of California, Riverside, and as a lecturer at Boston University.
David's books include Helping People Help Themselves and The Democratic Worker-Owned Firm, both of which have been highly regarded in the fields of economics and organizational theory. He has also written extensively for academic journals and popular outlets, contributing to the discourse on economic development, property theory, and worker ownership. David holds his BA in Mathematics from MIT and his PhD in Economics from Boston University.
Work with Dart: Dart is the CEO and co-founder of the work design firm 11fold. Build work that makes employees feel alive, connected to their work, and focused on what’s most important to the business. Book a call at 11fold.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode