The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 2 - Ranking the top QBs in the NFL playoffs, did Dante Moore make a mistake?
Jan 16, 2026
Former NFL player Teron Armstead, a five-time Pro Bowl offensive tackle, joins to analyze the playoff landscape. He shares insights on the top-ranked quarterbacks, including his defense of Josh Allen's talent and discuss the challenges faced by players like Sam Darnold. The conversation shifts to coaching dynamics, with Armstead evaluating Mike McDaniel's creativity and leadership. They even tackle the decision of Oregon QB Dante Moore returning to college, debating the risks and rewards tied to his choice.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Bo Nix's Seed vs. Proven QB Status
- Jason ranks Brock Bo Nix last among the eight divisional QBs despite Portland's 14-3 record because of limited downfield accuracy and playoff inexperience.
- He warns early success under Sean Payton doesn't yet prove Bo Nix is a long-term franchise QB.
Turnovers And Defense Mask QB Value
- Jason puts Sam Darnold and C.J. Stroud low because both rely heavily on defense and other factors rather than dominant QB play.
- He notes turnovers and defensive touchdowns have masked true quarterback performance in playoff wins.
Caleb Williams: Clutch With Growth Ahead
- Jason names Caleb Williams as clutch and rapidly improving, citing game-saving throws under pressure.
- He frames Williams as a future top QB but keeps him mid-list due to relative inexperience.