Why I Worry Every Time Someone Says to “Follow the Science” w/ Georgia Howe
Sep 19, 2024
auto_awesome
Georgia Howe, a contributor at The Daily Wire, dives into why she cautions against the mantra of 'follow the science.' She discusses the vital distinction between knowledge and wisdom, urging a critical examination of scientific claims, especially in politically charged contexts. Howe emphasizes the impact of political pressures on scientific integrity and the importance of public engagement to rebuild trust. With sharp insights, she explores how to separate credible science from flawed research, especially in high-stakes scenarios.
The podcast highlights that knowledge without wisdom can lead to morally questionable decisions, exemplified by historic scientists' flawed views despite their accolades.
It emphasizes the need for science to maintain its integrity and independence from political influence, encouraging the public to engage critically with scientific claims.
Deep dives
The Distinction Between Knowledge and Wisdom
Knowledge alone cannot guarantee wisdom, as the podcast highlights the limitations of relying purely on facts acquired through science. While impressive in depth, scientific knowledge often does not encompass the complex moral and ethical considerations required for sound decision-making. This is illustrated by historical figures in science who, despite their Nobel prizes, held views that today are considered morally reprehensible. Such examples underscore the necessity of incorporating life experience and wisdom alongside knowledge in scientific discourse.
Politics and Science: A Complex Relationship
The tension between scientific integrity and political influence is a central theme, emphasizing that science should remain an apolitical discipline. It is dangerous to conflate scientific authority with that of elected officials, as science thrives on questioning and debate rather than blind obedience. The podcast underscores the importance of not yielding to the notion that all scientists agree, warning that trust in scientific consensus can overshadow critical thinking. This dynamic underlines the necessity for the public to remain skeptically engaged with scientific claims, particularly those impacting everyday life.
Encouraging Public Engagement in Science
Rebuilding trust between scientists and the public requires active engagement and communication from both sides. Scientists, as public servants funded by taxpayers, have an obligation to present their findings in accessible language, enabling informed public discourse. In turn, laypeople are encouraged to demand clear, understandable answers and to remain involved in scientific discussions. This reciprocal relationship can foster a more transparent and trustworthy environment in which science operates as a collaborative effort between experts and the public.
But every time someone says to “follow the science,” I worry.
Why?
Find out in my conversation with Georgia Howe from The Daily Wire. The Daily Wire is a news website and media company founded in 2015 by political commentator Ben Shapiro and film director Jeremy Boreing.