Anthony Gregory, a historian of the American State and author of 'New Deal Law and Order', dives into the dramatic transformation of crime and governance in 1930s America. He discusses how the Great Depression shaped federal crime policies and the rise of figures like J. Edgar Hoover. The conversation touches on the dual approach of rehabilitation versus enforcement in Roosevelt's New Deal, the evolution of the FBI, and even the peculiar history of Coca-Cola's original cocaine content. It's a fascinating look at crime's role in modern political thought.
The New Deal expanded federal authority significantly, reshaping expectations regarding government intervention in crime and social welfare programs.
Franklin Roosevelt's collaborative governance approach, highlighted by strengthening the FBI, transformed law enforcement and redefined state-federal relations in crime control.
Deep dives
The New Deal's Transformative Impact
The New Deal initiated a significant expansion of the U.S. government under President Franklin Roosevelt, fundamentally reshaping Americans' expectations of government intervention in daily life. This transformation included the establishment of key social safety net programs such as Social Security and the FDIC, which are still in place today. However, the New Deal also faced criticism from those who viewed it as an overreach, arguing it infringed upon individual freedoms and paved the way toward a welfare state. This debate over the legitimacy of the New Deal still influences contemporary political discourse surrounding liberalism and conservatism.
The Emergence of the Law and Order State
The early 1930s presented significant challenges related to crime and lawlessness, exacerbated by the Great Depression and the failure of Prohibition. As gangsters like Bonnie and Clyde and John Dillinger gained notoriety, the federal government was compelled to develop a more robust response to crime, resulting in a redefined law and order state. This involved collaboration between federal and state authorities, reflecting a shift toward a more active role of the government in maintaining social order and addressing illegal activities. Such movements laid the groundwork for the modern understanding of crime control in the United States.
Roosevelt's Political Maneuvering
Franklin Roosevelt's awareness of crime's political implications shaped his approach to governance during the New Deal. Following his experience as Governor of New York, where he witnessed local corruption and political challenges, Roosevelt promoted a collaborative vision for addressing crime that brought together various political factions. His Attorney General, Homer Cummings, played a crucial role in strengthening the FBI and expanding its authority, thus establishing a foundation for modern policing. This cooperative federalism changed how local and federal governments interact concerning law enforcement and crime prevention.
Expansion of Federal Powers and Its Legacy
The New Deal era marked a substantial increase in the federal government's authority to address issues related to crime, including drug and firearms regulations, with laws like the Marijuana Tax Act of 1937. Roosevelt's administration effectively utilized tax laws as tools for regulating and prohibiting substances, illustrating a shift in governance strategies. The post-New Deal landscape shows that the ideological battle over the role of government—balancing security, freedom, and state power—remains relevant today. As questions of law and order continue to shape American politics, the decisions made during the New Deal era have enduring consequences on contemporary societal dynamics.
How did the United States go from a country defined by its lawlessness in the 1920s and early 1930s, to one where many political standpoints rest on a War on Crime? What roles did FDR, J. Edgar Hoover and Attorney General Homer S. Cummings play in this?
In this episode of American History Hit, Don delves into the transformation of the Federal government during Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal. He is joined by Anthony Gregory, historian of the American State and author of 'New Deal Law and Order: How the War on Crime Built the Modern Liberal State'.
Produced and edited by Sophie Gee. Senior Producer was Charlotte Long.
Enjoy unlimited access to award-winning original documentaries that are released weekly and AD-FREE podcasts. Get a subscription for $1 per month for 3 months with code AMERICANHISTORY sign up at https://historyhit.com/subscription/