Join Stuart Adam, a Senior Economist at IFS specializing in housing taxation, and Tim Leunig, an economist from the London School of Economics with a rich advisory background, as they delve into the UK housing market's struggles. They discuss how taxes like stamp duty and council tax impact affordability and market dynamics. The conversation highlights inequities in the tax system, challenges for landlords, and proposes reforms to address the ongoing housing crisis. Discover how these tax policies shape housing choices and the broader economic landscape.
The UK housing market is hindered by a regressive tax system that fails to reflect current property values, necessitating urgent reform.
Stamp duty creates disincentives for homeowners to move, thus limiting mobility and exacerbating housing market inefficiencies.
Deep dives
The Current Housing Tax Landscape
The UK housing market faces significant challenges, primarily driven by issues of affordability and availability due to the tax system's structure. Key taxes affecting the housing sector include council tax and stamp duty, which are seen as problematic due to their regressive nature and outdated valuation methods. The current council tax system is based on property values from 1991, creating inequities where properties of vastly different values may incur similar tax bills. As a result, there is a growing consensus that reforms are necessary to make the tax system more equitable and reflective of current property values.
Council Tax: A Defunct System
The council tax system has faced criticism for its inability to adapt to economic changes and for favoring properties built before the 1991 valuations. The tax disproportionately burdens local governments while failing to generate sufficient revenue to meet increasing needs, such as adult social care and temporary accommodations for the homeless. Additionally, the single person discount incentivizes individuals to occupy larger homes unnecessarily, exacerbating housing inefficiencies. The need for reform is clear, as current practices do not align with the realities of the housing market or local government funding requirements.
Stamp Duty's Disincentive Effect
Stamp duty serves as a tax on home purchases, discouraging people from moving homes by adding significant costs each time a property changes hands. This disincentive can prevent individuals from downsizing or relocating for work, subsequently locking them into properties they may no longer value as highly. The revenue generated from stamp duty has increased with rising house prices, but this growth does not correspond to a thriving housing market or increased mobility for homeowners. The overall sentiment is that abolishing or reforming stamp duty could lead to a more dynamic housing market and encourage people to occupy homes that better match their circumstances.
Tax Bias Against Renting
The current tax system in the UK disproportionately advantages owner-occupiers over renters, leading to higher costs in the rental market. Landlords face multiple taxation layers, including income tax on rental income and capital gains tax, contributing to escalating rent prices for tenants. As government policies increasingly favor home ownership, the rental market's viability diminishes, compounding the economic strain on renters. Ultimately, there’s a clear recognition that increasing housing supply in desirable locations is essential to resolve the crisis affecting both renters and homeowners alike.
The UK’s housing market has long been a source of frustration for renters and homeowners alike, with issues of affordability and availability topping the agenda. The new government has identified housing market failures as a major barrier to economic growth—but what role does the tax system play in these challenges?
In this episode, we’ll dig into how taxes impact the housing market, from the cost of buying and renting to the incentives—or disincentives—they create for landlords, developers, and homeowners. We’ll explore everything from capital gains tax to stamp duty surcharges and council tax policies. Are these tax measures helping or hindering progress? And if reform is needed, where should policymakers begin?
To help answer those questions, Paul is joined by Stuart Adam, Senior Economist at IFS and Tim Leunig, economist at the London School of Economics and former Economic Advisor to Sajid Javid and Rishi Sunak.
Become a member: https://ifs.org.uk/individual-membership
Find out more: https://ifs.org.uk/podcasts-explainers-and-calculators/podcasts