The Thomistic Institute

Augustine and Aquinas Against Skepticism – Prof. Chad Pecknold

Jan 16, 2026
Chad C. Pecknold, a renowned Catholic theologian and professor, explores skepticism's roots and its impact on morality. He argues that modern skepticism stems from a loss of connection to God, an insight traced back to Augustine and Aquinas. Pecknold explains how metaphysical realism affirms the mind's capacity to know truth. Delving into historical philosophical shifts, he illustrates how nominalism has led to contemporary views of constructed reality, all while emphasizing that genuine morality is essential for understanding Christ as Truth.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Skepticism Rooted In Divine Detachment

  • Skepticism rises when people detach from God and deny an intelligent cause of reality.
  • Augustine views skepticism as a religious and metaphysical problem that undermines intelligibility.
INSIGHT

Existence As The Common Ground

  • The first Athenian academy discovered that 'existence' is the common feature of all things, enabling metaphysical realism.
  • Plato concludes an uncaused cause (being itself) grounds intelligibility and breaks the imminent frame.
ANECDOTE

Two Travelers Illustrate Trust Vs Doubt

  • Augustine compares two travelers to show how trust leads to arrival while radical doubt prevents reaching a destination.
  • The poor peasant who trusts directions arrives, unlike the skeptical aristocrat who never truly trusts guidance.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app