Colin Horgan, a Toronto-based writer known for his insights on algorithmic pricing, discusses the fascinating world of personalized pricing in online shopping. He reveals how algorithms set different prices for the same item, influenced by factors like location and shopping history. Horgan contrasts personalized pricing with traditional dynamic pricing, exploring its implications on fairness and accessibility. The conversation also highlights the need for transparency in data usage and the growing role of AI in shaping consumer experiences.
Dynamic pricing algorithms utilize extensive user data and behavior to adjust prices, often leading to different charges for similar items.
The rise of personalized pricing raises significant concerns regarding data privacy and transparency, leaving consumers unaware of potential discrimination.
Deep dives
Understanding Dynamic and Personalized Pricing
Dynamic and personalized pricing has become a common practice in online shopping, influenced by algorithms that utilize user data to set prices. This strategy allows companies to adjust prices based on supply and demand, as well as individual consumer behavior, thereby determining the maximum price a user is likely to pay without disengaging. A notable example is Orbitz, which started displaying higher hotel rates to Apple users based on their purchasing habits, demonstrating how user data can skew pricing. This raises concerns about fairness, as consumers may unknowingly pay different prices for the same item at different times or from different locations.
Impact of Algorithms on Consumer Choices
While these pricing algorithms aim to maximize profits and even potentially lower prices for certain consumers, the reality often reflects hidden biases and challenges. Research indicates that algorithms can unintentionally lead to outcomes resembling collusion, where prices remain stable rather than competitive. Moreover, the prevalence of drop shipping and frequent price adjustments on platforms like Amazon streamlines competition but limits consumer options by favoring sellers who can rapidly adapt to price fluctuations. Consequently, this narrowing of choices can leave consumers feeling as if they have fewer options than they truly do.
Concerns Over Data Privacy and Regulation
The increasing use of personalized pricing has sparked significant concerns about data privacy and the transparency of the pricing process. Consumers often lack awareness of the data collected about them, which influences the prices they encounter online, leaving them in the dark about potential price discrimination. Current regulations struggle to keep pace with the rapid developments in algorithmic pricing, and while some countries are exploring measures to enhance transparency, meaningful oversight remains elusive. As technology evolves, there is a pressing need for consumers to gain more control over their personal data and understanding of the online purchasing landscape.
With some already starting their holiday shopping, we bring you an episode from our vault on dynamic pricing. Enjoy!
---------------------------------
You and a friend might be given two different prices by the same website for the same item. Heck, you might be given two different prices yourself depending on where you are when you're browsing the site. It's a phenomenon that began as dynamic pricing—a computer balancing supply and demand to ensure everything was sold at a price the market was prepared to pay—but it's now gone well beyond that.
As algorithms become smarter and more advanced, and as we voluntarily offer our devices and the companies we do business with more of our information, the prices you see may take into account things like where you are, what device you're on, your shopping history and... well, everything the machine knows about you. Is this the kind of shopping experience we want? If not, what do we do about it?
GUEST: Colin Horgan, writing in The Walrus
We love feedback at The Big Story, as well as suggestions for future episodes. You can find us: