Peter Kellner, an award-winning pollster and former President of YouGov, delves into the implications of Keir Starmer's controversial decision to raise defense spending at the expense of foreign aid. As they discuss the waning influence of centrism in British politics, Kellner poses thought-provoking questions about military readiness and the possible return of tougher stances against figures like Trump. The light-hearted extra segment also reflects on childhood films, examining their enduring impact on political perspectives.
Keir Starmer's decision to raise defence spending while cutting foreign aid highlights a significant ideological rift within the Labour Party regarding national security versus humanitarian support.
The decline of centrism is evident as public sentiment shifts towards more radical movements, with many voters disillusioned by the effectiveness of centrist politics in addressing pressing issues.
Concerns about defence procurement process inefficiencies suggest a need for reforms to ensure that increased military investments translate into genuine advancements for British military technology.
Deep dives
The Role of Defence Spending and Foreign Aid
The recent decision to increase defence spending while cutting foreign aid has sparked significant debate within the Labour Party. Keir Starmer's announcement to raise defence expenditure to 2.5% of GDP has been criticized as sacrificing international aid at a time when global cooperation is vital. Critics highlight the dichotomy of prioritizing national security over humanitarian support, arguing that reducing aid undermines Britain's standing on the world stage. The conversation reflects a broader realization in Europe regarding the necessity of self-reliance in defence following shifts in U.S. foreign policy.
Centrism's Decline and Political Mockery
Centrism is becoming increasingly mocked and viewed as outdated within the political landscape, with figures like the 'centrist dad' embodying this discourse. This figure represents a viewpoint perceived as condescending and overly simplistic, struggling to engage with the complexities of modern governance. The rise of more radical political movements suggests that many voters feel disillusioned with centrist parties, viewing them as ineffective at addressing pressing issues. This shift raises concerns about the future of centrist politics, as public sentiment increasingly gravitates toward more extreme positions.
Populism and the Crisis of the Mainstream
The growing dissatisfaction with centrist politics has led to the rise of populist sentiments, with voters expressing a desire for fundamental change. Research indicates that frustrations stem not merely from ideological divides but from a belief that government systems have failed to deliver effective solutions. Both mainstream parties are urged to recognize this disenchantment and adapt their messaging, focusing on competence rather than simply reacting to populist rhetoric. Failure to address these challenges may result in further erosion of the traditional party structures, leading to increased support for more extreme alternatives.
Implications of Increased Defence Procurement
The discussion surrounding the increased defence budget raises concerns about how this investment will translate into meaningful military capability. Suggestions have been made that reforming defence procurement processes could lead to economic growth by fostering innovative British companies in military technology. However, there is skepticism about whether the existing structures can effectively manage such funds due to historical inefficiencies. The procurement landscape must evolve to ensure that investments lead to real advancements, rather than simply being absorbed by established conglomerates.
Concerns About Public Sentiment on Immigration
Public attitudes towards immigration are complex, with a significant portion expressing concerns about immigration levels while paradoxically supporting specific categories of immigrants necessary for various sectors. The issue reveals a broader disconnect, where negative perceptions are often targeted at abstract concepts instead of individual contributions from immigrants. Political parties are challenged to construct more nuanced narratives that highlight the benefits of immigration, moving beyond economic arguments to personal stories. Creating a comprehensive immigration strategy that communicates its value effectively is essential for countering populist rhetoric.
Keir Starmer’s decision to raise defence spending and cut foreign aid has raised a whole load of questions (but not any asked by Kemi Badenoch because she’s, like, really bad at that). Is cutting aid the right choice? Are we ready for war? And is this the start of Starmer being tougher towards Trump? Plus: is centrism dead? Award-winning pollster and former President of YouGov Peter Kellner joins us to discuss why it just might be. And in the Extra Bit for Patreon backers, Boris Johnson keeps referring to Jaws – a film that was out when he was 11 years old. Which movies from when the panel were 11 left an impression on them…?
We’re on YouTube!: https://www.youtube.com/@ohgodwhatnow
Presented by Ros Taylor, with Rachel Cunliffe, and Marie Le Conte. Producer: Chris Jones Audio production by: Robin Leeburn. Group Editor: Andrew Harrison. Managing Editor: Jacob Jarvis. OH GOD, WHAT NOW? is a Podmasters production.
