Historiansplaining podcast host Sam Biagetti and Michael explore the rise and fall of the failed messiah Shabbatai. They discuss the historical context, controversies, and reactions to Shabbatai's claims of being the Messiah. They also delve into the tragedies and crisis of the 16th and 17th centuries, the role of Kabbalah in understanding crisis, and the formation of a Creole faith surrounding Shabbatai.
Sabatates Vi's messianic movement gained momentum through deliberate provocations and breaking traditional taboos, conveying a sense of overturning norms as a sign of imminent redemption.
The majority of Jewish laypeople, especially those experiencing hardship, embraced Sabatates Vi's messianic movement fervently, leading to economic disruptions and an intense period of messianic anticipation.
The messianic movement surrounding Sabatates Vi attracted attention from gentiles, sparking theological debates and discussions as they tried to make sense of this phenomenon.
Deep dives
Sabatates Vi, the Tormented Rabbi: Rise of a Messianic Movement
Sabatates Vi, a rabbi from Smyrna in the Ottoman Empire, became a central figure in a messianic movement in the 17th century. Initially seen as a tormented soul, he sought spiritual insight and traveled to Jerusalem, where he heard of a mystical teacher named Nathan of Gaza. Nathan proclaimed that Sabatates Vi was the Messiah, and the movement gained traction in Jewish communities in Palestine, Syria, and beyond. Sabatates Vi embraced his role, performing innovative rituals and breaking traditional taboos to convey the imminent arrival of the Messianic age. Followers, including laypeople and rabbis, enthusiastically embraced the movement, while some skeptics remained wary. The movement also attracted attention from gentiles, who perceived Sabatates Vi as the second coming of Christ. The excitement and fervor surrounding Sabatates Vi's messianic claims led to social and economic disruptions, with businesses shutting down and ports closing. Despite opposition and skepticism from certain quarters, the movement continued to build momentum until Sabatates Vi's arrest in Constantinople, where he remained imprisoned, and his followers continued to visit him. The movement caused intense speculation and contemplation, and its repercussions reached beyond the Jewish community, attracting attention from both supporters and skeptics. Sabatates Vi's story is a striking example of the power of messianic fervor and the complexities of religious movements in historical contexts.
The Influence of Kabbalah and Spiritual Redemption
The rise of Sabatates Vi's messianic movement was influenced by the growing popularity of Kabbalah, a Jewish mystical tradition, in the 15th and 16th centuries. Kabbalah provided a spiritual interpretation of Jewish history and emphasized the individual's role in bringing about the Messianic age through personal spiritual growth and redemption. This shift in Messianic belief from a focus on a militaristic and political Messiah to a more spiritual understanding allowed Sabatates Vi to gain followers who saw him as a tormented but spiritually powerful figure. The movement's rituals and acts were deliberately provocative, breaking traditional taboos and conveying a sense of overturning established norms as a sign of the imminent redemption.
Reactions and Spread of the Movement
The reaction to Sabatates Vi's messianic claims varied among Jewish communities. Some rabbis and scholars offered cautious support, believing that his tormented nature aligned with the suffering of the Jewish people and interpreted his actions as signs of the Messianic age. Others, particularly in more established and prestigious communities, resisted and questioned the movement. Yet, the majority of Jews, especially laypeople experiencing hardship and poverty, embraced the movement fervently. The movement spread throughout Jewish communities in Palestine, Syria, and beyond, leading to economic disruptions, widespread penitence, and an intense period of messianic anticipation.
Gentile Interest and Sabatates Vi's Imprisonment
The messianic movement surrounding Sabatates Vi also attracted attention from gentiles. Some gentiles believed he was the second coming of Christ, while others were intrigued by the fervor and disruptions caused by the movement. The Ottoman authorities, concerned about the influence and potential chaos caused by the movement, arrested Sabatates Vi and imprisoned him in Gallipoli. However, his imprisonment did not diminish the excitement and the visitation of followers, who continued to flock to him and seek his guidance. The movement's repercussions went beyond the Jewish community, igniting theological debates and discussions among gentiles as they tried to make sense of this messianic phenomenon.
Sabatai converts to Islam under pressure from Turkish authorities
Sabatai, feeling threatened by the Turkish authorities, journeyed back to Poland but returned to Judaism. However, the incident with Nehemiah caused the Turkish authorities to take action. They feared that the situation would escalate into fights, civil war, or mass conversions to Islam. Sabatai was brought before the Sultan's privy council and given an ultimatum: convert to Islam or be tortured and killed. Sabatai chose to convert, was given an Islamic name, and embraced Islam.
Sabatai and his followers develop a new belief system
After his conversion, Sabatai's followers had to grapple with the shock and disillusionment. Some rejected him outright, while others tried to explain or justify his conversion. One explanation was that Sabatai was going into the realm of darkness and evil to redeem it. They believed his apostasy was part of a larger spiritual mission to gather sparks of goodness and redeem both Jews and gentiles. Over time, these beliefs evolved into a syncretic faith that combined elements of Judaism and Islam, with a focus on universal redemption.
In a special crossover episode, @Historiansplaining podcast host Sam Biagetti and Michael kick off our Shabbatai series by doing a deep dive into the facts, foibles and little known intricacies of the failed messiah's rise and fall. Visit our website to ask us questions at xaihowareyou.com and call or Text the Talmud Hotline at 401-484-1619 and leave us a voicemail! Support us on patreon at patreon.com/xaihowareyou. Follow us on twitter @xaihowareyou and @miss_figured. Music by Ben Schreiber.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode