The Real Science of Sport Podcast Follow Up: Did Malcolm Gladwell Need To Apologise for Trans Stance?
11 snips
Sep 4, 2025 Malcolm Gladwell's controversial comments on trans athletes sparked significant media backlash. The hosts discuss the media's portrayal and misrepresentation of his statements, frustrating those advocating for women's sports. They dive into the heated debate from the 2022 Sports Analytics Conference, highlighting the complex interplay of journalism and advocacy. The challenges of navigating the trans rights discourse are explored, emphasizing the need for neutrality and a balanced approach. Evolving views on trans inclusion in women's sports reflect broader societal shifts in public sentiment.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Viral Clips Distort Long Conversations
- Social media can reduce a long, nuanced interview to a viral 30-second clip that shapes public perception.
- Ross Tucker says this truncation hides valuable context and frustrates experts who gave extensive, thoughtful input.
Who Was On The MIT Sloan Panel
- The MIT Sloan debate panel included Malcolm Gladwell as moderator, Katie Barnes as an advocate, Joanna Harper as a researcher, and Ross Tucker as a scientist.
- Ross recalls Barnes acted as an advocate rather than a neutral journalist during the discussion.
Testosterone Suppression Lost Scientific Support
- Joanna Harper's early research offered a testosterone-suppression solution that the IOC and others adopted as policy.
- By 2022 many sports concluded that suppression did not remove male advantages and policies began to shift.