Can Democracy Coexist With Big Tech? with Marietje Schaake
Sep 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Marietje Schaake, an international technology policy expert and former European parliamentarian, warns of a looming 'Tech Coup' undermining democracy. She discusses how Big Tech's grip erodes privacy and human rights. Schaake emphasizes the urgent need for regulation to maintain democratic principles amidst rapid technological advancement. She critiques the accountability of tech giants in crises and advocates for grassroots movements to ensure innovation serves the public interest rather than corporate power. This conversation is both enlightening and alarming!
Marietje Schaake warns that the unchecked power of both big and small tech companies threatens democratic values and individual rights.
The podcast emphasizes the need for effective regulations to balance innovation with public interest, urging a collective approach for accountability in technology governance.
Deep dives
The Rise of Technology Companies and their Impact on Democracy
The podcast discusses how the increasing power of technology companies poses a threat to democracy. It references examples such as the Cambridge Analytica scandal to highlight the potential harms these firms can inflict, particularly on children and society at large. Maricja Schaka emphasizes that a lack of regulation has allowed tech companies to act without accountability, leading to decisions that can undermine democratic values. The conversation underscores the urgent need for a governance model that can balance innovation with the protection of democratic principles.
The Role of Governance in Regulating Technology
Schaka outlines the failures of various U.S. administrations to effectively regulate technology companies, resulting in a legacy of inaction that has empowered these firms. She argues that governments must reclaim their oversight role to ensure that technology serves public interests rather than solely corporate profits. The discussion touches on the importance of enacting regulations that not only mitigate risks posed by big tech but also address the challenges posed by smaller tech companies specializing in invasive technologies. This regulatory approach could shift the power dynamics between tech firms and democratic institutions.
Innovation vs. Democracy: Challenging Assumptions
The podcast questions the prevailing belief that innovation should be prioritized above all else, positing that if innovation comes at the cost of democratic integrity, it isn’t worth pursuing. Schaka asserts that regulations can foster innovation rather than stifle it, offering the automotive industry as an example where regulation has historically encouraged growth. The discussion emphasizes the need to re-evaluate what constitutes beneficial innovation, advocating for a focus on advancements that serve societal interests rather than merely economic ones. This reevaluation challenges the traditional view of innovation as an unqualified good.
Constructing a Democratic Future in the Age of Technology
Schaka advocates for a collaborative approach to technology governance, stressing that accountability mechanisms need to be built into both companies and governments. She highlights the importance of collective action from civil society, including parents and national security experts, to create pressure for necessary changes. The podcast suggests that a grassroots movement could be more effective in instigating change than top-down regulation alone, reflecting a skepticism about government transparency and accountability. By fostering a democratic dialogue about technology, individuals can become active participants in shaping their future in a tech-driven world.
International technology policy expert, Stanford University academic, and former European parliamentarian Marietje Schaake writes in her new book that a “Tech Coup” is happening in democratic societies and fast approaching the point of no return. Both Big Tech and smaller companies are participating in it, through the provision of spyware, microchips, facial recognition, and other technologies that erode privacy, speech, and other human rights. These technologies shift power to the tech companies at the expense of the public and democratic institutions, Schaake writes.
Schaake joins Bethany and Luigi to discuss proposals for reversing this shift of power and maintaining the balance between innovation and regulation in the digital age. If a "tech coup" is really underway, how did we get here? And if so, how can we safeguard democracy and individual rights in an era of algorithmic governance and surveillance capitalism?
Marietje Schaake’s new book, “The Tech Coup: Saving Democracy From Silicon Valley,” is available here. Read an excerpt from the book on ProMarkethere.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode