I Can't Decide Which Property to Buy for My Next Airbnb

✅ FREE tool and training to find your own Super Property: https://go.buildstrwealth.com/superpropertygrader

💸Baselane: Get $100 when you sign up and put your rental finances on autopilot—no monthly fees, no stress: https://baselane.com/str-wealth?

Struggling to choose between two great Airbnb properties? You're not alone. I'm breaking down the exact decision-making process I use when I’ve got two top contenders. One’s a private beach townhouse with insane VRBO upside. The other’s a mountain property with built-in wedding venue income and big tax advantages. I walk you through how I analyze cash flow, appreciation, and bonus depreciation—plus what tools I use to run the numbers the right way.

00:00 – When Even I Can’t Decide on a Property

01:12 – Beach vs. Mountain: The Two Properties I’m Torn Between

03:00 – This Beach Property Has a Secret Advantage Most Miss

05:05 – $110K in Passive Income? The Mountain Property’s Wildcard

07:18 – Which One Wins on Cash Flow (And Which One Doesn’t)

09:04 – How Appreciation Could Flip the Decision

11:22 – The Hidden Tax Play Most Investors Ignore

13:05 – My Framework for Underwriting a Property

15:10 – Why I Don’t Start With a Pro Forma (And What I Do First)

17:28 – The Real Secret to Making Smarter STR Investment Calls

Mentioned in this episode:

This episode is brought to you by StayFi — the easiest way to grow your direct bookings! ⁠ Visit stayfi.com/bill and use code "BILL" for an exclusive 50% off your first three months.