Ben Keyes, a Wharton professor and expert on housing markets, discusses the U.S. housing shortage of approximately 4 million homes. He links the crisis to the 2008 financial meltdown and highlights how climate change exacerbates the situation. Keyes explores soaring prices, interest rates, and innovative solutions, including repurposing federal properties. He also addresses the rising insurance costs tied to climate impacts and demographic shifts affecting homeownership, particularly in risk-prone areas like Florida.
The U.S. faces a critical housing shortage of approximately 4 million homes, significantly impacted by high costs and zoning regulations.
Climate change exacerbates housing affordability issues by driving up property insurance costs, particularly in areas vulnerable to natural disasters.
Deep dives
Housing Affordability Crisis
The current housing market is characterized by a severe lack of affordable options, primarily due to high home prices and elevated interest rates, making homeownership and renting increasingly unattainable. The situation has worsened since the financial crisis of 2008, which led to a halt in construction and a long-term shortage of housing stock. Estimates indicate that the U.S. is short about four million houses, contributing to an environment where individuals are spending significantly on housing, with renters typically plying 30% of their income. This crisis is further exacerbated by a sluggish new construction rate and a market in which many homeowners opt to stay put rather than sell, adding to the housing scarcity.
Barriers to New Construction
Three critical barriers hinder the increase of housing supply: high costs of materials and labor, difficulties in financing construction projects, and strict zoning regulations. Rising costs for building materials, driven by inflation, alongside a tight labor market, have made it challenging for builders to take on new projects. Additionally, obtaining financing for large-scale apartment buildings can be complex and difficult. Lastly, zoning and land use policies often create convoluted processes that developers must navigate, further hampering the potential for faster housing development.
Impact of Climate Change on Housing
Climate change directly influences costs associated with homeownership, particularly through the rising expenses of property insurance. Research shows that from 2020 to 2023, property insurance costs nationally increased by over 33%, with even larger hikes in vulnerable areas at risk of climate-related events, such as hurricanes and wildfires. This problem disrupts the predictability of homeownership, as homeowners face escalating insurance costs that can undermine budgeting and financial planning. Moreover, demographic shifts show an increasing number of people moving into danger zones, compounding the risks associated with property insurance.
Successful Housing Initiatives
Some cities have begun implementing innovative strategies to combat the housing crisis, such as Minneapolis, which reduced zoning barriers to create more attainable housing options. The city's actions were a proactive response to its housing challenges, enabling sensible densification around transit hubs and improving access to affordable living spaces. Additionally, other areas like Alabama have explored fortifying properties to withstand climate impacts, showcasing potential models for resilience alongside housing development. With forward-thinking policies and community engagement, these examples demonstrate that significant progress is possible in rebuilding housing stock and addressing affordability challenges.
The U.S. is short approximately 4 million homes. Wharton professor Ben Keys traces the beginning of the housing crisis to the 2008 financial meltdown — and says climate change is making things worse.
Also, Justin Chang reviews the Iranian film The Seed of the Sacred Film.