Joining the discussion are Greg Lukianoff, the President and CEO of FIRE and co-author of "The Canceling of the American Mind," and Rikki Schlott, a New York Post columnist. They delve into the evolving nature of cancel culture, reflecting on its ties to academic freedom and personal anecdotes. The duo also weighs in on high-profile cancelation cases and the impact of social media in shaping public opinion. Is cancel culture on the decline? They explore this provocative question and advocate for dialogue over demands for cancellation.
The collaboration between students and administrators since 2014 has fundamentally altered the dynamics of free expression on college campuses.
Cancel culture has evolved into a widespread phenomenon that impacts various sectors, including comedy, media, and even children's educational environments.
Recent political developments show that both left and right factions increasingly engage in cancel culture, complicating the landscape for free speech advocacy.
Deep dives
The Alliance Between Students and Administrators
A significant dynamic in cancel culture emerges from the collaboration between students and administrators, challenging traditional notions of free expression. This alliance is marked by a shift observed around 2014, when students began actively pushing for disciplinary actions against educators for their speech. These actions diverge from historical student behaviors, where disagreements with professors typically led to dialogue rather than campaigns for termination. This indicates a troubling trend where both parties engage in settling scores, revealing a deeper cultural transformation in educational institutions.
Understanding the Roots of Cancel Culture
Cancel culture is defined as the increase of campaigns aimed at penalizing individuals for their speech since around 2014. This phenomenon encompasses calls for firing or ostracizing individuals based on protected speech, particularly in environments where First Amendment protections may not apply. By intricately analyzing this historical development, the conversation elucidates how such campaigns manifest and the chilling effects they generate. This understanding is crucial for addressing the negative implications on both academic freedom and social discourse.
Real-life Impacts of Cancel Culture on Individuals
The personal stories surrounding cancel culture emphasize its profound effects on individuals' lives, often leading to devastating outcomes. One poignant example involves the tragic case of a professor facing severe repercussions after expressing controversial opinions, culminating in his suicide following intense public backlash. This heartbreaking narrative illustrates the real human cost of cancel campaigns, shedding light on the emotional toll and the consequences of a culture that prioritizes punitive action over dialogue. Such cases challenge the ethics of cancel culture and the responsibility of both peer groups and institutions to foster open expression.
Cancel Culture's Broader Social Context
Cancel culture transcends college campuses, permeating various sectors such as comedy, media, and corporate environments, demonstrating its widespread influence. Numerous accounts reveal how even children in schools face repercussions for their parents’ political affiliations or opinions, highlighting the pervasive nature of this cultural phenomenon. The impact on science and medicine also raises alarms, as ideological conformity could undermine the scientific method, particularly during crises like the COVID-19 pandemic. These examples underscore the urgent need for a cultural shift towards tolerance and open dialogue across all domains of society.
The Evolving Nature of Cancel Culture and Political Backlash
The discussion emphasizes that while cancel culture remains prevalent, its manifestations are evolving alongside broader political forces. Recent events have shown a disturbing trend where both left- and right-wing factions engage in canceling, often employing state power to exert control over speech. This complicates the landscape, where traditional cancel culture dynamics are compounded by governmental actions against dissenting voices. Understanding this evolving context is critical for advocating a culture that values free speech and dialogue over punitive action.
The co-authors of “The Canceling of the American Mind” discuss its new paperback release and where cancel culture stands a year and a half after the book’s original publication.
23:51 Alexi McCammond, former Teen Vogue editor-in-chief
31:57 Echo chambers on social media
35:09 Trump administration ‘canceling’ law firms and higher ed institutions
44:02 Rikki’s libertarian political identity
51:02 Is cancel culture dead?
54:26 Outro
Enjoy listening to the podcast? Donate to FIRE today and get exclusive content like member webinars, special episodes, and more. If you became a FIRE Member through a donation to FIRE at thefire.org and would like access to Substack’s paid subscriber podcast feed, please email sotospeak@thefire.org.
