Ep 21: Ajay Shah on {x}kdr forum and why knowledge can't be produced on contract
Jun 22, 2024
auto_awesome
Ajay Shah, a prominent figure involved with the {x}kdr forum, returns to discuss crucial topics in Indian development. He shares insights into how the forum identifies and tackles pressing challenges, emphasizing the need for innovative problem-solving. The conversation highlights the role of knowledge production amidst India's complex funding landscape, the critique of traditional academic limitations, and the significance of fostering enthusiasm and collaboration in intellectual culture. Shah also reflects on redefining success and the importance of personal growth.
Dr. Ajay Shah emphasizes that the XKDR Forum tackles India's development challenges by strategically prioritizing complex issues to maximize societal impact.
The podcast highlights the struggle for securing funding in India, as the XKDR Forum navigates the intersection of capability, interest, and financial backing.
Dr. Shah argues that authentic knowledge production thrives on intellectual freedom rather than contractual obligations, promoting genuine contributions to India's developmental narrative.
Deep dives
Founding XKDR Forum and Its Mission
The founder of XKDR Forum, Dr. Rajesh, discusses his motivations for establishing the organization, which focuses on addressing critical issues in India's development landscape. He emphasizes the importance of tackling pressing problems systematically, advocating that organizations must prioritize their focus areas to maximize impact. In particular, he highlights the significance of sustained intellectual work in understanding and addressing complex societal challenges. The journey has been both rewarding and challenging, given the difficulty in securing funding for innovative intellectual endeavors.
Resource Allocation Challenges
Dr. Rajesh describes the complexities of securing resources for academic and research-focused initiatives in India. He illustrates this with a Venn diagram that balances the intersection of what the organization is capable of doing, what they enjoy doing, and what they can be funded to do. The struggle to align these aspects has been crucial in shaping the strategic direction of the XKDR Forum. This resourcefulness is particularly necessary in the current Indian funding landscape, which often favors more traditional or visible projects.
Knowledge Production vs. Consulting
The conversation touches on the distinction between knowledge production and consulting work, with Dr. Rajesh arguing that genuine knowledge cannot be produced on a contractual basis. He asserts that knowledge production thrives on curiosity, enthusiasm, and intellectual freedom, which may often be stifled within the consulting framework that responds to client demands. The importance of this philosophy is underscored as the XKDR Forum seeks to produce valuable insights without being hampered by external expectations. This approach further supports their mission of contributing genuinely to India's developmental narrative.
Advancing Indian Development Strategy
Dr. Rajesh expresses dissatisfaction with the current level of engagement in foundational areas of India's development strategy, such as economic growth and the evolution of the private sector. He admits that while the XKDR Forum engages in pro bono work to nurture curiosity in these fields, substantial contributions are limited. This illustrates a desire for greater involvement in shaping critical knowledge that aligns with India's economic ambitions. He advocates for deeper exploration of these areas as vital for realizing the full potential of India's development journey.
Organizational Culture and Structure
The conversation dives into the organizational design of the XKDR Forum, which aims to maintain a small team of around 20 people to foster deep collaboration and individual growth. Dr. Rajesh believes that this size allows for a vibrant intellectual culture where each member can contribute significantly without the burdens of bureaucratic overhead. However, he acknowledges the limitations of such a small structure in terms of broader influence in the field. This conscious choice underscores a commitment to creating a rich internal environment devoted to knowledge and cultural development.
Shaping Future Knowledge Production
The importance of producing original knowledge rather than merely summarizing existing thinking is a key focus for the XKDR Forum. Dr. Rajesh emphasizes the need for researchers to generate new ideas that contribute to understanding India in profound ways. By challenging themselves to offer fresh perspectives, the organization aims to fill the gaps in the current knowledge landscape. This forwards a broader conversation about the unique role research organizations like XKDR Forum play in advocating for innovative thinking in the Indian ecosystem.
In this episode I am speaking with second time guest on the show, Dr. Ajay Shah about {x}kdr forum and the problems it solves. We speak about how the organisation chooses problems to solve, how they contribute to the Indian developmental story, how Ajay manages to be as enthusiastic about solving big problems as he was 20 years ago, and much more.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode