Jennifer Greenburg, "At War with Women: Military Humanitarianism and Imperial Feminism in an Era of Permanent War" (Cornell UP, 2023)
Jan 11, 2025
auto_awesome
Jennifer Greenburg, a political geographer and lecturer at the University of Sheffield, discusses her book, which examines the intersection of military humanitarianism and feminist discourse post-9/11. She reveals how U.S. military strategies transformed to incorporate women in combat roles, raising questions about imperial feminism. Greenburg critiques the romanticized narratives around women's rights in warfare and highlights the conflicting dynamics between gender, military training, and humanitarian efforts, emphasizing the need to reconsider traditional feminist perspectives.
Dr. Jennifer Greenburg critiques the role of imperial feminism in justifying military interventions, revealing its impact on gender dynamics and military strategies.
The podcast discusses how the U.S. military leveraged humanitarian efforts in counterinsurgency, challenging traditional narratives of women's rights and role in combat.
Deep dives
Carla’s Internet Upgrade
Upgrading to multi-gig speeds from Cox has significantly improved Carla's connectivity, ensuring that all her high-tech devices work seamlessly. This upgrade highlights the importance of having a reliable internet connection to support modern technology and various online activities. Even the best tech can falter if the internet speed doesn’t meet its needs. Enhanced internet capabilities bring a smoother experience for tasks like streaming, gaming, and remote work.
The Disappearance of Four Teens in Brooklyn
In the summer of 1994, the mysterious case of four teenagers who vanished in Gravesend, Brooklyn captured attention, leaving their families longing for answers. Despite extensive investigations, the lack of witnesses and clues caused the case to grow cold, impacting the lives of the victims' loved ones. A breakthrough emerged in 2024 when Anthony Brewer obtained DNA evidence that didn’t match any of the teens, leading to new revelations and heightened danger for him and his family. This development not only reignited discussions about the case but also the tangible risks faced by individuals seeking justice.
Dr. Jennifer Greenberg’s Book on Military Humanitarianism
Dr. Jennifer Greenberg, a political geographer, focuses her book on the intersection of military actions, humanitarianism, and feminism in the post-9/11 era. She examines how the narrative of women's rights was initially used to justify military interventions like those in Afghanistan. Her research reveals a deeper analysis of the colonial histories that inform current military strategies and the role of women within these frameworks. By employing ethnographic and archival methods, she sheds light on the complexities of U.S. hegemony and gendered practices in the military.
Counterinsurgency and Gender Dynamics
The discourse around counterinsurgency strategies evolved significantly by 2006, recognizing the interconnectedness of military and development efforts in conflict zones. The U.S. military began viewing NGOs as 'force multipliers' to win hearts and minds during operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. Greenberg highlights how historical narratives were often invoked in training sessions, emphasizing the colonial roots of military tactics. She spotlights the impact on female soldiers who were deployed in both combat and humanitarian roles, illustrating the contradictions they faced in their identities and duties.
At War with Women: Military Humanitarianism and Imperial Feminism in an Era of Permanent War (Cornell University Press, 2023) by Jennifer Greenburg reveals how post-9/11 politics of gender and development have transformed US military power. In the mid-2000s, the US military used development as a weapon as it revived counterinsurgency in Iraq and Afghanistan. The military assembled all-female teams to reach households and wage war through development projects in the battle for "hearts and minds." Despite women technically being banned from ground combat units, the all-female teams were drawn into combat nonetheless. Based on ethnographic fieldwork observing military trainings, this book challenges liberal feminist narratives that justified the Afghanistan War in the name of women's rights and celebrated women's integration into combat as a victory for gender equality.
Dr. Jennifer Greenburg critically interrogates a new imperial feminism and its central role in securing US hegemony. Women's incorporation into combat through emotional labor has reinforced gender stereotypes, with counterinsurgency framing female soldiers as global ambassadors for women's rights. This book provides an analysis of US imperialism that keeps the present in tension with the past, clarifying where colonial ideologies of race, gender, and sexuality have resurfaced and how they are changing today.
This interview was conducted by Dr. Miranda Melcher whose new book focuses on post-conflict military integration, understanding treaty negotiation and implementation in civil war contexts, with qualitative analysis of the Angolan and Mozambican civil wars.