Mass cuts at TVNZ – but are they enough? And NZME's podcast drama, explained
Nov 11, 2024
auto_awesome
Glen Kyne, a media commentator and expert on the New Zealand media landscape, dives into the recent upheaval at TVNZ, including proposed job cuts and the shift of news to a content unit. He also unpacks the drama surrounding podcast star Frances Cook and her former employer, NZME, shedding light on the evolving relationship between legacy media and digital platforms. They discuss how political influences and the upcoming election could reshape the media landscape, raising concerns about the power dynamics between traditional media and new content creators.
TVNZ's proposed redundancies aim to save costs amidst declining broadcast viewership, but the restructuring may compromise journalistic integrity and audience engagement.
The fallout from Frances Cook's departure from NZME highlights critical issues of content ownership and management in the evolving landscape of digital media.
Deep dives
TVNZ's Financial Challenges
TVNZ is facing significant financial challenges, with proposals in place to achieve $30 million in savings. Plans include restructuring staffing, with discussions around reducing 90 jobs primarily in production and news areas. There is a concern about how these changes will impact audience engagement and revenue, especially since broadcast television is experiencing a sharp decline. The restructuring raises questions about whether the proposed measures will be sufficient to stabilize the organization in a rapidly digitizing media landscape.
Impact of Leadership Changes
Recent changes in leadership at TVNZ include shifting the head of news from direct reporting to the CEO to reporting to the head of content. This unconventional structure could undermine the newsroom's independence, potentially leading to conflicts between editorial decisions and executive interests. It raises concerns about how newsroom staff will perceive these changes, as well as how they may affect the integrity of news coverage. Maintaining a balance between managing costs and preserving journalistic credibility is critical in this evolving media environment.
Francis Cook's Controversial Exit
The departure of Francis Cook from NZME reveals significant issues around intellectual property and management practices in the media industry. Cook's popular podcast, Cooking the Books, became embroiled in ownership disputes after a company merger led to content removal from platforms like Spotify. This situation underscores the lack of clear guidelines regarding content ownership in a rapidly evolving digital environment. The fallout has implications not only for Cook but also for the future of content creators within traditional media structures.
Evolving Dynamics of Trust in News Media
The relationship between traditional news media and voters is shifting, with a notable decline in trust in established institutions. The recent election showcased how user-generated content and social media may now influence political outcomes more significantly than traditional coverage. An increasing number of people are turning to alternative media sources, suggesting a broader trend of skepticism towards institutional narratives. This trend raises concerns about democracy, as the divergence in media consumption habits could create polarized voter bases reliant on curated information that aligns with their beliefs.
Glen Kyne returns to The Fold to dissect the 50 proposed redundancies at TVNZ, and the confirmation that news will now be part of content, rather than its own unit. Next, they analyse the extraordinary drama between podcast star Frances Cook and her former employer, NZME – particularly what it says about legacy media's relationship with digital. Finally, they talk about Trump's election, and what that means for big tech and the waning power of institutional media.