Join James Chappel, Gilhuly Family Associate Professor of History at Duke University, as he unpacks how the 1935 Social Security Act revolutionized American perceptions of aging. He highlights shifts from stigmatized language to dignified terms like 'senior citizens.' The discussion dives into the impact of advocacy groups, the evolution of retirement from elites to the working class, and Florida's rise as a retirement hotspot. Chappel emphasizes the importance of recognizing older individuals' active roles in society and calls for innovative approaches to aging policy.
The passage of the 1935 Social Security Act marked a transformative shift in American perceptions of aging, leading to a more dignified identity for older adults.
Activist organizations played a pivotal role in shaping aging policies and narratives in America, advocating for equity and justice for older generations throughout history.
Deep dives
The Concept of Old Age in American Society
The perception of old age in America began to shift significantly around the time of the 1935 Social Security Act, which marked a pivotal moment in how society viewed older individuals. Prior to this era, the term 'the aged' was commonly used, reflecting a stigmatizing notion that older people required help and were a burden. The establishment of Social Security provided older adults with secure income, transforming their status from that of the aged to 'senior citizens,' a term that emerged in the post-World War II period as older individuals began to assert a more dignified identity. This evolution reflects a broader cultural transformation in the United States regarding the role and respect afforded to older generations.
Stages of Aging Terminology
The discussion of aging in America can be categorized into three distinct stages, each characterized by a different terminology that reflects societal attitudes. Initially, older individuals were referred to as 'the aged,' which conveyed a sense of dependency and neediness. Following the establishment of Social Security, the term 'senior citizens' became popular, representing a more empowered identity as individuals sought to define themselves as active contributors to society rather than dependents. Today, the term 'older people' is preferred, moving away from both previous classifications and emphasizing equality and the idea that aging does not equate to diminished capability or worth.
Myths and Misconceptions Surrounding Aging
The podcast challenges prevalent myths regarding aging in America, asserting that anxieties about how the elderly are treated often arise from misinformation and outdated cultural models. Comparisons are commonly made to other countries or historical contexts that supposedly provide better care for older generations, yet these notions are frequently oversimplified or misunderstood. For example, the idea that cultures in places like China revere their elders is sometimes contrasted with American attitudes, but such comparisons can overlook the complexities of care and respect. The discussion suggests that rather than viewing aging as a societal failure, there are many aspects of American aging policy and culture that have advanced positively over the last century.
The Role of Activism in Shaping Aging Policies
Activist organizations have played a crucial role in shaping the narrative and policies surrounding aging in America, notably before the rise of the AARP in the 1980s. The Ex-Slave Pension Society emerged in the early 20th century, advocating for compensations for older black individuals who had endured decades of uncompensated labor, while other organizations, such as the Paternal Order of Eagles, sought to provide pensions for white older adults. The opposition and competition among these groups illustrate the creative tension within aging advocacy, culminating in significant moments like the Social Security Act. The podcast emphasizes that this history shows a dynamic struggle for justice and equity among older generations that should not be forgotten in contemporary discussions about aging.
When did old age in America first begin? That is, when did we first begin to conceive ideas about a stage of life in which older people no longer participated in the labor force, but nevertheless had a meaningful place in the world, deserving of respect, security, and dignity.
My guest James Chappel argues that this is an idea that became prominent in the American consciousness at a certain point in time–namely, the 1935 Social Security Act. It was, he believes, one of the key moments in the cultural transformations of how Americans think about old age, and how we treat the aged. These ideas and moments were shaped by activists, practical politicians, medical advancements, and cultural models ranging from Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward to the TV show “The Golden Girls.”
James Chappel is the Gilhuly Family Associate Professor of History at Duke University and a senior fellow at the Duke Aging Center. The author of Catholic Modern, his interests are in the intellectual history of modern Europe and the United States, focusing on themes of religion, gender, and the family. He lives in Durham, North Carolina. His most recent book is The Golden Years: How Americans Invented and Reinvented Old Age, and it is the subject of our conversation today.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode