Slate Daily Feed What Next | Is the Gaza Deal Real?
Oct 7, 2025
Yair Rosenberg, a staff writer at The Atlantic and author of Deep Shtetl, dives into the complexities of the Gaza negotiations. He discusses Trump's bold 20-point ceasefire plan, expressing skepticism about its authenticity. The conversation highlights Hamas's cautious acceptance and the temporary wave of hope it brought. Yair also breaks down the challenges of achieving lasting peace, including Netanyahu's political pressure and the intricate dynamics of negotiation. Tune in to learn what could shift the landscape in the coming days.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Fait Accompli Versus Reality
- Trump presented a 20-point Gaza plan as a fait accompli despite many unresolved details.
- Yair Rosenberg warns that salesmanship doesn’t equal a real, enforceable deal.
Qualified Yes Sparks Hope
- Hamas gave a qualified response that Trump treated as acceptance and pushed talks to Cairo.
- Rosenberg notes this prompted cautious optimism among civilians on both sides.
Gaza City Advance Drives Urgency
- Israel escalated toward conquering Gaza City, displacing many civilians, which increased pressure to negotiate.
- Rosenberg frames the ceasefire push as a last chance to avoid a major urban assault.