Shameless Popery #185 What Makes a War “Just?” - Joe Heschmeyer
7 snips
Jun 26, 2025 The podcast dives deep into the just war theory amid global conflicts like Israel, Hamas, and Iran. It explores the ethical dilemmas surrounding military intervention and the philosophical tensions between pacifism and state authority. Christian teachings on justice are examined, challenging common perceptions of Jesus as a radical pacifist. Biblical perspectives on vengeance are dissected, highlighting the moral complexities involved. Lastly, the relationship between civil authority and divine commands is discussed, emphasizing the need for just causes in conflict.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Pacifism vs State Violence
- Strict pacifism is impractical because state violence enforces law and order.
- Elizabeth Anscombe argues Christianity supports just use of force to maintain peace.
Turn The Other Cheek Explained
- Jesus' command to "turn the other cheek" is likely an evangelical counsel, not a universal law.
- Treating radical nonviolence as a strict rule leads to unrealistic and harmful moral outcomes.
Pope Francis on Just War
- Pope Francis rejects the idea of "holy war" but supports lawful self-defense.
- The Church limits just war to defensive actions, not aggressive invasions.
