CNLP 689 | DeSizing the Church, The Drug of Size, The Good and Bad of the Church Growth Movement, and What Small and Large Churches Get Right
Nov 12, 2024
auto_awesome
Karl Vaters, an experienced pastor and author, shares insights on the concept of 'desizing' the church in today’s context. He discusses the obsession with church size and its pitfalls, advocating for a focus on spiritual health rather than numbers. Vaters highlights the unique strengths of both small and large congregations and the unintended consequences of the church growth movement. He also emphasizes the need for genuine leadership and community engagement over simple numerical success.
The pressure for continual growth in congregations can lead to pastor dissatisfaction, highlighting the need to redefine success beyond numerical metrics.
Discipleship plays a critical role in church health, addressing challenges and fostering deeper faith within congregations, regardless of church size.
Pastors have unique affinities for small or large church contexts, and recognizing this fit can enhance their effectiveness and well-being in ministry.
Deep dives
The Challenge of Church Size Expectations
The podcast discusses the pressure on pastors to achieve continual growth in their congregations. Many pastors feel burdened by an implicit expectation to increase attendance year after year, leading to stress and dissatisfaction. This pressure is particularly pronounced in the context of the church growth movement, which emphasizes numerical success as a measure of ministry effectiveness. The conversation suggests that this focus on size can overshadow the true mission of the church, which is to serve and impact lives meaningfully.
Defining Success Beyond Numbers
One key insight shared is the need to redefine success in ministry beyond numerical metrics. The idea is proposed that personal and spiritual health should be measured through qualitative factors instead of attendance figures. Success can be evaluated by examining stories of transformation, community involvement, and effective discipleship. This shift in perspective helps pastors focus on meaningful ministry outcomes rather than just the size of their congregations.
Understanding Church Wiring for Growth
The podcast highlights the concept that pastors might have a natural affinity for either small or large church contexts, comparing it to having a 'shoe size.' This notion suggests that every pastor has a capacity or fit within specific church settings, influencing their effectiveness and well-being. For instance, a pastor who is more suited to a small church may struggle in a large context, leading to dissatisfaction and even burnout. Recognizing this wiring can help pastors embrace their unique calling and align their ministry efforts accordingly.
The Importance of Discipleship
A significant point made during the discussion is the critical role of discipleship in church health and growth. The podcast argues that genuine discipleship can address many challenges churches face today, from lack of engagement to moral failures among leaders. By investing in discipleship, churches can cultivate stronger relationships and a deeper faith in the congregation. This emphasis on developing disciples can create transformative environments where church members grow and thrive, irrespective of the church size.
Navigating the Celebrity Culture in Ministry
The conversation also critiques the culture of celebrity within church leadership, noting its potential to lead to moral failings. As large platforms and attention become increasingly desirable, the risk is that aspiring leaders may prioritize popularity over integrity and service. The podcast suggests that rather than chasing numbers or fame, church leaders should focus on their personal integrity and discipleship efforts. By staying grounded and authentic, leaders can avoid the pitfalls of public ministry while making a genuine impact in their communities.
Getting in front of the people who need your message most can seem like a mystery. Gloo+ automates direct mail to 50 new families to your community and connects you with up to 7 people who are looking for answers your church has.
Just go to Gloo.us/connection and use the code CAREYSAVE20 for an additional 20% off your subscription.