Dr. H.A. Hellyer, a Middle East expert and Senior Associate Fellow at RUSI, explores the recent ceasefire between Israel and Hamas. He discusses the ambiguity of the deal and its potential for renewal of hostilities, citing external influences like Trump’s involvement. Hellyer shares insights on Hamas’s governance challenges and the future of Gaza post-conflict. The conversation highlights a fragile sense of hope and the complexities of diplomacy in the region, reflecting on the historical context of peace efforts.
The newly established ceasefire agreement offers a temporary reprieve from violence but remains fragile amid skepticism about its longevity.
Internal Israeli politics, particularly Benjamin Netanyahu's maneuvering, significantly impact the conflict's trajectory and future governance of Gaza.
Deep dives
Ceasefire Agreement in Gaza
A new ceasefire agreement has been reached between Israel and Hamas, marking a notable development in a prolonged conflict. This deal includes a phased release of hostages and Palestinian prisoners, introducing a potential six-week ceasefire meant to reduce violence and allow humanitarian aid into Gaza. However, skepticism remains regarding the durability of this ceasefire, as past deals often result in escalated attacks soon after announcements are made. Despite the optimism surrounding the agreement, the reality on the ground suggests ongoing instability and the need for more comprehensive discussions about lasting peace.
Impact of Domestic Politics on the Conflict
Benjamin Netanyahu's political landscape is intricately tied to the ongoing conflict, with pressure from both domestic and international sources influencing his decisions. The involvement of the Trump administration has been perceived as a catalyst for pursuing a ceasefire, with questions arising about Netanyahu's intentions to prolong the conflict for political survival. Reports indicate that internal Israeli politics may actually benefit Netanyahu's position, as ending the war could ignite scrutiny and calls for accountability regarding past actions. Thus, the intricate balance of power and public sentiment in Israel plays a crucial role in shaping the future trajectory of the conflict.
Hamas's Future and Regional Dynamics
Hamas faces a challenging future as discussions emerge about its role following the ceasefire and the potential governance of Gaza. While there appears to be a significant decline in support for Hamas among some Palestinians, the group's longstanding presence suggests that it is not likely to disappear entirely. The issue of who will govern Gaza in the event of a power shift remains complicated, particularly given the Palestinian Authority’s tenuous standing and Israeli opposition to their involvement. The wider geopolitical landscape, including the roles of regional powers like Qatar and Saudi Arabia, will significantly influence reconstruction efforts and the dynamics of peace in the region.
After 15 months of horror, a ceasefire and hostage release deal triggers rejoicing in Israel and Palestine. But the deal is ambiguous and built around only a gradual release of Palestinian prisoners and Israeli hostages, with no agreement to end the war yet. While Trump rushes to claim credit, some fear the deal is so loose it might collapse. Could this conflict reignite? Gavin Esler talks to Middle East expert Dr H.A. Hellyer of RUSI, the Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security, about Israel and Gaza’s fragile moment of hope.
• From next week TINAD will be coming out every Thursday instead of Wednesdays, to give us more time to react to developing news stories. Patreon people will still get episodes as early as possible.
• This episode of This Is Not A Drill is supported by Incogni, the service that keeps your private information safe, protects you from identity theft and keeps your data from being sold. There’s a special offer for This Is Not A Drill listeners – go to Incogni.com/notadrill to get an exclusive 60% off your annual plan.
• Support This Is Not Drill on Patreon to continue by backing us on Patreon. You’ll get early, ad-free editions, merchandise and more.
Written and presented by Gavin Esler. Audio production by Robin Leeburn. Original theme music by Paul Hartnoll – https://www.orbitalofficial.com. Executive Producer Martin Bojtos. Group Editor Andrew Harrison. This Is Not A Drill is a Podmasters production