Topics discussed in this podcast include the decline of Norman Maynard's essay, the parallels between Trump and characters in Dickens' novels, seeking justice and restitution for Black Americans, exploring Tanhisi Coates' evolving ideas, Nietzsche's slave revolt and imaginary revenge, the substance and process in politics, and upcoming episodes on great political novels and bad ideas.
Norman Mailer's essay 'Superman Comes to the Supermarket' combines the surface of American politics with underlying tensions and wildness of the nation.
The influence of Donald Trump in global politics may be emblematic of a larger trend, but other politicians might have inspired his approach as well.
Reparations for black Americans involve complex considerations, including means of achieving them, who pays, and potential risks and implications.
Deep dives
The Importance of Reading Norman Mailer's Essay
In this podcast episode, Norman Mailer's essay 'Superman Comes to the Supermarket' is discussed. The essay, published in 1960, explores the Democratic Party Convention of that year and the rise of John F. Kennedy as a glamorous and groundbreaking political figure. However, the essay is also critiqued for being dated and overwritten, lacking the depth and journey-like quality of great essays. It is suggested that Mailer's essay combines the surface of American politics with the underlying tensions and wildness of the nation. Additionally, the debate arises whether Mailer's declining popularity is due to his unpleasant personality or the essay's shortcomings.
The Influence of Trump in Politics
The podcast addresses the extensive focus on Donald Trump in political discussions, despite the essays not being directly about him. The question is raised about whether Trump is the template and other politicians worldwide are following his lead, or if Trump himself emulates something bigger in politics. It is acknowledged that the influence of Trump may be emblematic of a larger global political trend, but it is also noted that other politicians might have inspired Trump's approach. The potential impact of Trump's re-election and the consequences of ongoing discussions about him are considered.
The Question of Reparations for Black Americans
The podcast explores the question of reparations for black Americans, referencing Tanahasi Coates' essay and its argument for reparations. The discussion delves into the complexities of seeking reparations, including the means through which it can be achieved, such as litigation or legislation. It is highlighted that the process and how it is implemented are crucial aspects to consider. The question of who pays for reparations is also pondered, with the suggestion that it could be funded through general public funds as opposed to targeting specific groups. The parallels between West German reparations to Israel and demands for reparations after World War I are also examined, noting the potential risks and implications associated with different approaches.
Anger, Revenge, and the Line Between Them
The podcast episode delves into the distinction between anger and hatred, drawing on James Baldwin's perspective. The relationship between anger and Nietzsche's concept of imaginary revenge, or rasontamour, is explored. The concept of imaginary revenge is outlined as a form of revenge that occurs exclusively in the realm of ideas and explores the means of imposing constraints on those who oppress through the use of conceptual codes. The discussion emphasizes the complexity of the relationship between anger, revenge, and the line between them, highlighting that they are intertwined in various contexts and can have different manifestations in different situations.
Substance and Process in Politics
The distinction between substance and process in politics is examined in the podcast. Substance refers to the focus on what needs to be done or the desired outcomes, while process pertains to how those outcomes can be achieved. It is noted that there is often an imbalance, with too much emphasis on the substance at the expense of considering the practical steps and implications. The significance of examining both substance and process is highlighted, as they are inherently interconnected and equally important in politics. The tension between them is acknowledged, and the need to strike a balance is emphasized for effective political discussions and decision-making.
For our last episode before Christmas David answers some of your questions about the History of Ideas series – What would Dickens have made of Trump? How would reparations work? Which essays are missing from the list?
Coming up: the whole series on the great essays, one a day, every day, starting on Christmas Day.