Fr. Cajetan Cuddy, O.P., a Dominican priest and scholar on Aquinas, delves into the moral nuances of just war theory. He explains how Aquinas views peace as more than the absence of conflict, emphasizing the importance of justice and charity in warfare. The discussion touches on the moral criteria for declaring war and the need for virtuous intentions. Fr. Cuddy highlights that military actions should align with moral virtue to achieve a greater good, ultimately guiding us toward lasting peace.
True peace is achieved through justice and charity, guiding human desires towards goodness and ultimately towards God.
In a just war, the primary goal must be peace, defined by legitimate authority, just cause, and right intention rather than conflict itself.
Deep dives
The Nature of Peace and Charity
Peace is fundamentally linked to justice and charity, as articulated in the teachings of St. Thomas Aquinas. Justice serves an indirect role in peace by eliminating obstacles, while charity fosters peace directly through unity with the highest good. Aquinas emphasizes that true peace emerges from the harmonious arrangement of human appetites towards goodness, which ultimately directs individuals towards God. Without this unifying force of charity, internal dissonance arises within individuals, impacting their pursuit of peace and happiness.
Intent and Purpose in Just War
In a just war, the primary intent must always be the attainment of peace, rather than destruction or chaos. Aquinas asserts that an end or goal shapes actions; hence, just war must be defined by its pursuit of peace, transcending the notion of conflict for conflict's sake. This intentionality is critical, as it delineates the nature of the war, requiring that participants recognize peace as the ultimate objective. A just war, therefore, represents a proactive measure taken against unjust forces to restore order and harmony within society.
Criteria for Just War
Three essential criteria define a just war according to Aquinas: legitimate authority, just cause, and right intention. The sovereign authority must declare war to ensure that the actions taken are not solely personal vendettas but aligned with the common good. Further, the cause of the war must address a legitimate grievance or wrongdoing, establishing a proportionality in response to an affront against peace. Finally, those engaged in the war must possess right intentions, aspiring to promote good and avoid evil rather than retaliating out of malice or personal injury.
Complexities of Warfare and Morality
Aquinas explores the moral intricacies surrounding ambush tactics and deceptive strategies in warfare, arguing that not all forms of deception equate to immorality. While lying to convey falsehoods is inherently wrong, withholding certain intentions or purposes does not violate moral law if it ultimately serves a greater good. This perspective opens a discussion about transparency versus necessary secrecy, highlighting that a total commitment to exposition may undermine genuine peace and solidarity. Consequently, the framework of just war should also embrace a strategic component that acknowledges the importance of maintaining justice and moral integrity.