John Gray, a renowned political philosopher and author of "The New Leviathans: Thoughts After Liberalism," delves into the state of liberalism and America's shifting identity. He discusses the significance of Trump's inaugural address and the liberal intelligentsia's reactions. Gray critiques the rise of nationalism and hyper-liberalism, questioning traditional moral beliefs. He also addresses the challenges of declining fertility rates, artificial intelligence's impact on jobs, and the complexities of identity in modern society.
Trump's presidency represents a complex coalition of populism and establishment interests, revealing deeper divisions within American political ideology.
The decline in birth rates raises critical socio-economic challenges, questioning national identity while navigating an increasingly individualized society.
Deep dives
The Impact of the Political Shift
The inauguration of Donald Trump marked a significant moment in American politics, generating a divided response across the nation. Half of the country expressed optimism and excitement, while the other half felt alarmed and defensive about the new administration. This polarization reveals deeper tensions within the political landscape, with the hyper-liberal intelligentsia grappling to understand and process the changes unfolding before them. The transition exemplifies a conflict between traditional liberal ideals and a burgeoning populist movement that rejects the status quo, marking a distinct shift in American political dynamics.
Contradictions of the Trump Era
Trump's presidency embodies a coalition of seemingly opposing forces, such as his self-portrayal as a champion of the working class while also aligning with tech oligarchs. This conflicting nature presents challenges that may strain political alliances, yet it is also a strategy that could sustain his administration's influence. Observers note that Trump's ability to thrive amid contradictions is indicative of a deeper political strategy focused on harnessing discontent. The potential fallout from his policies, particularly tariffs and executive actions, poses questions about their long-term impact on his support base and the overall economy.
America's Evolving Identity
The discussion around Trump also touches on a pivotal shift in how America perceives itself—no longer merely an idea but as a geographical entity with a unique historical destiny. The return to notions of American exceptionalism signals a departure from a purely ideological framework to one rooted in nationalism and traditional values. This shift evokes a sense of renewed ambition, reminiscent of earlier eras when America sought to define its role in the world based on its own identity rather than as a propagator of universal ideals. The challenges of this new approach include reconciling the roles of immigrants and diverse communities within the framework of a redefined American nationalism.
Challenges of Population Decline and Individualism
An emerging concern across the globe is the decline in birth rates, which poses existential questions for socio-economic structures, particularly in Western nations. Factors contributing to this trend include increasing individualism, financial insecurity, and shifting cultural priorities, leading many to prioritize personal fulfillment over traditional family structures. The resulting demographic changes raise critical questions about national identity and immigration policies, particularly in regions like Europe, where diverse populations are becoming more prominent. In the face of these transformations, addressing the complexities of population dynamics while embracing a more individualized society presents a substantial challenge for policymakers.
John Gray is a political philosopher. He retired from academia in 2007 as Professor of European Thought at the London School of Economics, and is now a regular contributor and lead reviewer at the New Statesman. He’s the author of two dozen books, and his latest is The New Leviathans: Thoughts After Liberalism. I’d say he’s one of the most brilliant minds of our time — and my first podcast with him was a huge hit. I asked him to come on this week to get a broader and deeper perspective on where we are now in the world. He didn’t disappoint.
For two clips of our convo — on the ways Trump represents peace, and how heterosexuals have become more like gays — pop over to our YouTube page.
Other topics: this week’s inauguration; the peaceful transfer of power; the panic of the left intelligentsia; the contradictions in the new Trump administration; Bannon vs Musk; Vivek’s quick exit; the techno-futurist oligarchs; Vance as the GOP’s future; tariffs and inflation; the federal debt; McKinley and the Gilded Age; Manifest Destiny; Greenland; isolationism; the neocon project to convert the world; Hobbes and “commodious living”; Malthus and today’s declining birthrates; post-industrial alienation; deaths of despair; Fukuyama’s “End of History”; Latinx; AI and knowledge workers; Plato; Pascal; Dante; CS Lewis’ Abolition of Man; pre-Christian paganism; Puritans and the woke; Žižek; Rod Dreher; Houellebecq; how submission can be liberating; Graham Greene; religion as an anchor; why converts are often so dangerous; Freudian repression; Orwell and goose-stepping; the revolution of consciousness after Christ; Star Wars as neo-Christian; Dune as neo-pagan; Foucault; Oakeshott’s lovers; Montaigne; Judith Shklar; Ross Douthat; the UK’s rape-gangs; Starmer and liberal legalism; the Thomist view of nature; the medieval view of abortion; late-term abortions; and assisted dying.
Browse the Dishcast archive for an episode you might enjoy (the first 102 are free in their entirety — subscribe to get everything else). Coming up: Sebastian Junger on near-death experiences, Jon Rauch on “Christianity’s Broken Bargain with Democracy,” Evan Wolfson on the history of marriage equality, Yoni Appelbaum on how America stopped building things, Nick Denton on the evolution of new media, and Ross Douthat on how everyone should be religious. Please send any guest recs, dissents, and other comments to dish@andrewsullivan.com.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode