

The semantic drift of "good"
6 snips Feb 21, 2025
Dive into the fascinating evolution of the word "good" as it shifts from nobility to utility. Discover how Nietzsche's insights reveal a radical redefinition by the oppressed. Unpack Shell's critique of modern morality influenced by capitalism and democracy. Explore McIntyre's thoughts on moral fragmentation in today's society. With a nod to Orwell's 1984, the discussion highlights the collapse of language and challenges the clarity of ethical discourse. Ultimately, the concept of "good" emerges as a term now stripped of its original significance.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Semantic Drift of "Good"
- "Good" has semantically drifted from an aristocratic self-affirmation to a utilitarian function.
- This shift reflects a change in moral values over time.
Nietzsche's Genealogy of "Good"
- Nietzsche argued "good" initially meant noble, signifying strength and high social standing.
- The lower classes, fueled by resentment, inverted this meaning, associating "good" with meekness.
Scheler's Critique of Modern Morality
- Modern morality, according to Scheler, is corrupted by utility, where "good" equates to usefulness.
- This aligns with capitalism and democracy, which prioritize functionality over inherent qualities.