Leaked Documents Indicate Secret Dealings Between Assad & Israel w/ Patrick Hilsman
Dec 19, 2024
auto_awesome
Journalist Patrick Hilsman, known for his work on conflicts in Syria and Ukraine, discusses leaked documents suggesting secret dealings between Assad's regime and Israel. These documents raise questions about the authenticity of regional alliances, especially regarding Hezbollah and Iran. Hilsman delves into the intriguing Israel-Russia relationship, particularly the influence of Israeli drone technology on Russian military tactics. The conversation also touches on the broader implications of Israel's export of surveillance technologies to authoritarian regimes, hinting at complex geopolitical relationships.
The leaked documents suggest a potential collaboration between the Assad regime and Israel regarding military operations against Iranian militias, raising questions about authenticity and historical context.
The complex relationship between Israel and Russia demonstrates that geopolitical alliances in the Middle East are often more nuanced and self-interested than simplistic narratives suggest.
Deep dives
Leaked Documents and Potential Syrian-Israeli Collaboration
Leaked documents suggest a possible collaboration between the Assad regime in Syria and Israel, particularly regarding military operations against Iranian militias. While the authenticity of these documents has not yet been verified, they indicate communications related to military strategy, including requests to divert aircraft carrying Iranian arms. The notion that these documents could be real raises questions about the historical context of Israel's actions in Syria, where it has conducted numerous airstrikes with apparent approval from Russian authorities, utilizing a deconfliction mechanism. This mechanism has allowed Israeli forces to bomb targets in Syria while avoiding confrontations with Syrian and Russian air defense systems.
The Historical Context of Israeli and Russian Relations
The relationship between Israel and Russia has deep historical roots that have evolved over time, especially following the Soviet Union's initial support for Israel. Notably, the modernization of Russia's drone technology has benefitted from Israeli expertise, reflecting a complex interplay between these two nations. Russian drones have been utilized to support the Syrian regime during its civil war, underscoring a pragmatic alliance that serves the strategic interests of both governments. This collaboration is often overlooked, as it complicates the narrative of clear-cut allies and enemies in Middle Eastern geopolitics.
The Complexity of Geopolitical Alliances in the Middle East
A critical discussion in the podcast revolves around the misconception of geopolitical alliances in the region, particularly the simplistic dichotomy often presented in Western narratives. Critics point out that viewing Iran and Israel as straightforward opponents fails to account for the intricate and often contradictory relationships among nations. The argument that Israel behaves solely as a U.S. ally is challenged by the evidence of its engagement with nations typically viewed as adversaries, such as Russia. This points to a more nuanced understanding of international relations where governments pursue self-interested policies that do not align neatly with ideological blocs.
The Humanitarian Perspective in the Syrian Conflict
Experiences from the Syrian conflict highlight the humanitarian crises resulting from geopolitical machinations, where civilian populations bear the brunt of political ambitions. The complexities within Syria, noted by those who have reported on the ground, reveal the dire conditions faced by ordinary people amidst the power struggles of external forces. This perspective emphasizes the importance of recognizing the human toll as various factions vie for control and influence, often disregarding the needs and rights of the local population. Understanding these dynamics offers deeper insights into the ongoing tragedy of the Syrian war and the roles of foreign leaders and governments.
On this edition of Parallax Views, journalist Patrick Hilsman, an editor at Turning Point Magazine, joins the show to discuss recent reports of leaked documents discovered after the overthrow of Assad in Syria that seem to reveal collaboration between the Assad regime and Israel. Although the documents have not been verified, the way the are written indicate they are either authentic or a carefully-crafted, elaborate hoax. Hilsman argues that if they are fake, and that is possible, they were written by someone incredibly well-researched. Hilsman will go into why there's some plausibility to the documents and how they relate to his reporting on the use of Israeli drones by Russia in, paradoxically, Syria itself. We'll go deep into the Israel-Russia relationship and how they have worked with each other over the years, especially in regard to weapons. In this regard Patrick recommends the book The Palestine Laboratory: How Israel Exports the Technology of Occupation Around the World. We'll also cover some odds and ends in both the Israel-Russia connections and how the relate to the leaked documents regarding Syria and Israel. Specifically, Patrick mention the Israel-Russia deconfliction line in relation to this story. The documents indicate that there were secret dealings between the Assad regime and Israel that were harmful to the Assad regime's ally Iran.
Patrick will also discuss his time in Syria reporting on the first battle of Aleppo in 2012 and his experiences there. We'll also delve into the problems with overly conspiratorial ways of thinking when talking about international relations, the oversimplicity of "good guys vs. bad guys" when discussing nation-states and nation-state alliances, Israel's actions in Gaza, and much more.
Guest Bio: Patrick Hilsman is a journalist and researcher who has covered the conflicts in Syria and Ukraine. He has been published by The Intercept, The Daily Beast and has had recent film work featured on PBS. He was a researcher for the Al Jazeera Documentary “the search for Assad’s executioners”
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode