In this conversation, guests Colin Kahl, Under Secretary of Defense for Policy; Mira Rapp-Hooper from the National Security Council; and Derek Chollet, Counselor of the State Department, reflect on the extraordinary legacy of Robert Jervis, their mentor. They share insights on Jervis's unique mentorship that combined psychological insights with policy analysis. The discussion touches on his approach to humility in scholarship, the importance of recognizing cognitive biases in leadership, and his influential theories on signaling in international relations.
Robert Jervis's scholarly work significantly influenced international relations theory and practical policymaking through his insights into human decision-making biases.
As a dedicated mentor, Jervis fostered an environment nurturing unconventional career paths for students who later held key positions in government.
Deep dives
Bob Jervis's Intellectual Legacy
Bob Jervis is recognized as a monumental figure in international relations, known for his profound scholarly contributions such as 'Logic of Images' and 'Perception and Misperception'. His work explored a variety of critical topics, including intelligence analysis and signaling, earning him the reputation of being the foremost scholar of his generation. His ideas not only advanced theoretical frameworks but also delved deeply into the practical applications of international relations, making his research particularly relevant. Jervis's legacy extends beyond his written work; he significantly influenced the next generation of policymakers by mentoring numerous students who have taken key roles in government.
Influence on Students and Policy
Bob Jervis was known for his commitment to nurturing his students, many of whom went on to hold influential positions in various administrations. His mentorship approach was characterized by an openness to unconventional career paths, encouraging his students to pursue their interests, whether in academia or policy. This supportive environment fostered a unique bond between Jervis and his students, who often cited personal anecdotes highlighting his unwavering belief in their potential. This reflection on mentorship showcases how Jervis's influence permeated both academic and practical realms, shaping the future landscape of international relations.
The Complexity of Decision-Making
A key insight from Jervis's scholarship is the understanding that human decision-making is laden with biases, particularly under the constraints of complexity and uncertainty. This framework is especially applicable to policymakers, who often face dilemmas in choosing strategies that involve significant trade-offs. Jervis’s emphasis on the perception of adversarial intentions underscores that decision-makers may not recognize their own limitations while overestimating the deliberate actions of others. This insight encourages a more nuanced approach to policy discussions, acknowledging that decision-making is not merely a calculation of rational choices but is influenced by cognitive biases and systemic pressures.
Engaging with Policy through Inquiry
Jervis maintained a genuine curiosity about human behavior and the nature of decision-making, which informed his contributions to both theory and practice in international relations. He advocated for a model of inquiry that emphasized understanding adversaries by considering their perspectives and motives, rather than imposing simplistic explanations. This approach was evident in his interactions with students and policymakers alike, as he encouraged critical questioning of underlying assumptions. By viewing policy debates through this lens, Jervis fostered a deeper understanding of the complexities involved in international interactions, thereby enhancing the practical relevance of academic insights.
Many of those who follow War on the Rocks and the Texas National Security Review mourned the passing of Robert Jervis, the towering scholar of international relations who defined a field and mentored generations of scholars and policymakers. Four of his close friends, colleagues, and protégés sat down to remember his legacy, his intellectual contributions, and his kindness. It is a fascinating discussion that touches on a variety of important issues related to international security. This episode, which is the first of two parts, is hosted by Francis Gavin of the Kissinger Center and chair of the editorial board of the Texas National Security Review. He is joined by Under Secretary of Defense for Policy Colin Kahl; Mira Rapp-Hooper, a member of the staff of the National Security Council, where she is responsible for an array of Indo-Pacific issues; and Derek Chollet, the counselor of the State Department. The views expressed here, of course, are personal and not those of the U.S. government.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode