3 and Out with John Middlekauff 3 & Out - Derek Carr Retires, Rookie mini-camp update, Brazil game is here to stay
May 12, 2025
Derek Carr's surprising retirement shakes up the NFL, prompting a discussion on his legacy and what might have been. Rookie mini-camp updates reveal how draft status becomes irrelevant as players compete for spots. Excitement builds around the NFL's commitment to games in Brazil, signaling a new chapter for international play. Plus, listener questions spark debates on coaching effectiveness and team dynamics. It's a captivating dive into the evolving landscape of professional football.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Derek Carr's Rookie Season Anecdote
- John Middlekauff shared his firsthand experience watching Derek Carr's rookie season preseason game against the Seahawks.
- Carr impressed by scoring multiple touchdowns and earning the starting job over Matt Schaub early on.
Impact of Family Legacy
- Derek Carr's career was negatively impacted by his brother's reputation as a bust.
- He was a second-round pick despite having talent worthy of a first-round selection.
Career Success Depends on Context
- Much of a quarterback's career success depends on uncontrollable factors like team stability and coaching.
- Carr played for a chaotic Raiders organization with frequent changes and relocations affecting his development.