Exploring Beaver Island (3 of 3)

Jul 28, 2025

Ask episode

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

Come see the site where James Strang was killed as we explore the captivating history of Beaver Island, a unique gem in Lake Michigan, especially its ties to James Strang and his Mormon community.

https://youtu.be/xdnR28tTeEs

Don’t miss our other conversations about Strangism: https://gospeltangents.com/denominations/strangites/

Gospel Tangents

Except for book reviews, no content may be reproduced without written permission.

3 Mormon Print Shop

Arrival and Reign of King Strang

James Strang, a self-proclaimed prophet, settled on Beaver Island around 1848, having arrived in 1847. He led a group of Mormon dissenters who broke away from Brigham Young’s leadership and settled on the island in 1846. By 1850, Strang was declared King of his community, which constituted the majority of the island’s population. The main hub of the island is even named St. James, after him. Strang’s influence extended to societal norms, where he apparently mandated that women wear bloomers or pants to prevent pneumonia, with husbands being whipped if their wives didn’t comply. He also reportedly told non-Mormons (like the Irish settlers and original Ottawa/Ojibwe inhabitants) that they needed to convert, leave, or pay a tax.

The Mormon Print Shop

A pivotal location in Strang’s community was the Old Mormon Printing House, erected in 1850 by Strang and his followers2. This building was significant as it published the Northern Islander, which was the first daily newspaper north of Grand Rapids. During the 1850s, Strang’s group published religious works and two newspapers: the Northern Islander and the Daily Northern Islander. After Strang’s assassination, the print shop was ransacked and later became a boarding house. Today, it stands as a museum and serves as the headquarters for the Beaver Island Historical Society.

Tragic End of King Strang

The growing friction within Beaver Island’s Mormon community reached a violent climax in 1856. James Jesse Strang was fatally shot and clubbed by two of his disgruntled followers while walking towards the dock to meet the captain of the USS Michigan. These assassins were reportedly hiding behind a woodpile near the Johnson McCulla store. It’s notable that two of the assassins were husbands who had been whipped under Strang’s controversial bloomers policy. Strang died from his wounds 23 days later. The assassins were taken to Mackinaw Island by the USS Michigan’s captain, who refused to allow the Mormon police to arrest them. They were soon released by the Mackinaw sheriff, celebrated by Strang’s enemies, and astonishingly, each was fined only 50 cents, though the exact charge is unknown.

The Aftermath and Island Life

In the wake of Strang’s assassination, an angry mob from the mainland stormed Beaver Island, destroying buildings and forcing the Mormons to flee. Beaver Island is the only island in Lake Michigan inhabited year-round, with a population of 500 to 800 people that swells to 3,000 in the summer. The island has a strong Irish presence, with many historical inhabitants speaking Gaelic and even naming a local bay “Donegal Bay” after a place in Ireland. Historically, the island’s primary industries were lumber and fishing. Overfishing, particularly using a now-outlawed net fishing method, led to severe depletion, prompting Michigan and other states to ban the practice. Today, tourism is the main industry. The island didn’t even get electricity until around 1939.

Beaver Island Townships Cemetery

Visitors can also explore the Beaver Island Townships Cemetery, one of two cemeteries on the island (the other being a Catholic cemetery). The oldest grave dates back to 1853, within James Strang’s era. An interesting feature of the cemetery is the presence of posts marking older graves where the original wooden crosses have long since deteriorated, indicating a body is buried there even if the identity is unknown. The second oldest grave, dated July 27, 1859, belongs to Mary Jane, wife of Thomas Hawkins. Notably, St. James Episcopal Church is located across the street from the cemetery.

Beaver Island offers a rich tapestry of history, from its unique religious past under James Strang to its evolving industries and enduring natural beauty. It’s a place where history comes alive, allowing visitors to walk in the footsteps of a fascinating and turbulent era.

Don’t miss our other conversations about Strangism: https://gospeltangents.com/denominations/strangites/

Gospel Tangents

Except for book reviews, no content may be reproduced without written permission.