The Secrets of Statecraft Robert Service on Lenin, Trotsky & Stalin | Secrets of Statecraft | Andrew Roberts | Hoover Institution
19 snips
Aug 9, 2024 Robert Service, a noted historian specializing in Russian history, dives deep into the turbulent legacies of Lenin, Trotsky, and Stalin. He explores Lenin's totalitarian ideologies and his disconnect with the populace, while contrasting him with Trotsky's complex legacy. The discussion touches on the historical context influencing Russian preferences for strong leaders, the significance of Soviet archives, and the potential alternative outcomes of pivotal events like the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk. His insights illuminate the intricate tapestry of Russian revolutionary history.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Ukraine Existed Before Lenin
- Vladimir Putin's essay denying Ukrainian identity is historically false because Ukraine existed politically before Lenin and in 1917 had its own armed units and governments.
- Lenin created a Soviet Ukrainian republic for political expediency, not because Ukraine lacked prior identity.
Baltics Are Vulnerable In Moscow's Narrative
- Putin has repeatedly signaled that Baltic borders are artificial and that Russian populations there could be a pretext for intervention.
- This rhetoric makes the Baltic states legitimately fearful if Ukraine falls.
Support Ukraine With Careful Arming
- Supply Ukraine with the weaponry it needs, short of provoking nuclear escalation.
- Continue support while Ukrainians want to keep fighting to preserve their chances.