Sed Contra: A Podcast of Catholic Theology Quodlibet 14: Is the Stock Market Sinful?
Sep 22, 2025
The hosts dive into the intriguing concept of Thomistic grace, discussing the interplay between divine permission of sin and human freedom. They tackle the ethical implications of stock market investing, comparing Aquinas' views on usury with modern practices. A fascinating exploration of the Pseudo-Dionysius reveals its enigmatic authorship and lasting impact on theology. Plus, there's an invitation for listeners to submit their questions for future discussions!
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Grace Can Be Infallible Yet Free
- Thomists distinguish irresistible grace from infallible (infructuous) grace to preserve freedom and merit.
- God could give infallible grace to all, but permitting some to fall serves goods we often cannot now see.
Permitting Sin For A Higher Good
- If God could save everyone, the reason he doesn't must be that some greater good requires not-all being saved.
- Medieval thinkers framed the problem as why God allows sin, not merely why hell exists.
Fallen Experience Can Shape Virtue
- God permits certain falls so creatures acquire virtues or goods unattainable otherwise.
- Suffering and humility from permitted evils can produce distinctive spiritual goods.
