Dr. Lauren Schwartz Part 2 | The Role of Psychiatry in Transgenderism
Dec 29, 2023
auto_awesome
Dr. Lauren Schwartz explores the role of psychiatry in transgenderism. They discuss the difference between validation and affirmation, social media's impact on youth anxieties, emotional impact on children, loss of foundational identity, and the irreversible consequences of hormone blockers. They also touch on the long-term physical effects of transitioning, the biological reality of chromosomes, and the power of language control.
The rush to transition children without evaluating the long-term effects poses significant risks to their well-being.
Gender affirming psychiatric care prioritizes subjective lived experiences over evidence-based medicine, raising concerns about its scientific validity and potential harm.
Affirmation and validation of a child's identity by authority figures can limit their ability to explore their identity or change their mind in the future.
Deep dives
The Rush to Transition
The podcast episode explores the rush to transition children and the alarming consequences of affirming gender dysphoria without critically evaluating the long-term effects. The speaker highlights the need for parents to protect their children, emphasizing the importance of having open conversations about identity and encouraging healthy development.
The Dangers of Gender Affirming Care
The podcast delves into the controversial concept of gender affirming psychiatric care, presented in a new textbook. The speaker expresses concerns about the subjective nature of the approach, which prioritizes lived experience over evidence-based medicine. The involvement of activists and the high number of transgender authors in the book raise questions about its scientific validity and potential harm to children.
The Impact of Affirmation and Validation
The podcast discusses the impact of affirmation and validation in a child's development. The speaker emphasizes the difference between celebrating and supporting a child's identity versus affirming and solidifying it. Affirmation by authority figures, such as teachers, can have psychological consequences and limit a child's ability to explore their identity or change their mind in the future.
The Influence of Social Media
The podcast highlights the influence of social media on children's perception of their identity. The speaker discusses how social media platforms create a sense of belonging and acceptance, but also contribute to the isolation and pressure children feel to conform to gender identities. This pressure can lead to anxiety and distress, hindering a child's ability to develop a strong sense of self.
The Need for Critical Evaluation and Protection
The podcast calls for a critical evaluation of gender dysphoria treatment and protection of children's well-being. The speaker emphasizes the importance of not rushing into irreversible medical interventions and raising awareness about the potential physical and psychological consequences. Parents are urged to be advocates for their children and ensure they have access to unbiased information and support.
[0:00] Welcome back to The Kathy Barnette Show. Kathy introduces Dr. Lauren Schwartz back to the listeners
[3:00] Dr. Schwartz explains the difference between validation and affirmation
[6:00] "Validating is not the same as affirming."
[10:00] Social media’s role in increasing anxieties among youth
[15:30] “Not every sense of discomfort is a negative thing. It tells us to move out of something and grow and expand our understanding of ourselves and why we're responding to something in an anxious way or depressed way.”
[17:30] Emotional impact on children and adolescents
[21:00] Loss of foundational identity pillars within the United States
[29:00] Difference between evidence-informed and evidence-based practice
[34:00] The irreversible consequences of hormone blockers
[46:45] Long-term physical effects of transitioning are unknown
[49:30] Gender ideology ignores the biological reality of chromosomes
[53:00] “He who controls language control rules the world.”
[56:00] Closing thoughts and advice for parents
Thanks for listening to this episode of The Kathy Barnette Show. Remember to subscribe for more insightful conversations, share this episode with those interested in understanding the deeper aspects of our government, and provide your feedback for future topics.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode