Harsh V Pant is a foreign policy expert at the Observer Research Foundation, and Pranab Dhal Samanta is the geopolitical guru at the Economic Times. They dive into the escalating tensions between India and Canada, sparked by allegations surrounding Hardeep Singh Nijjar's assassination. The discussion highlights historical ties, the influence of the Trudeau legacy, and how domestic politics shape foreign relations. They also assess the roles of major global players and the implications for trade amidst rising diplomatic strains.
The diplomatic crisis between India and Canada has escalated dramatically due to accusations of Indian involvement in the assassination of Hardeep Singh Nijjar.
Political dynamics and historical grievances have consistently influenced India-Canada relations, showcasing the challenges in managing diplomatic ties amidst domestic agendas.
Deep dives
Heightened Tensions Between India and Canada
Relations between India and Canada have dramatically escalated due to allegations involving the killing of Hardeep Singh Nidjar, a Canadian Sikh leader. The Canadian government has suggested a potential link between Indian government agents and this incident, leading India to strongly deny these assertions and label them as unfounded accusations. This situation is compounded by Canada's public identification of Indian diplomats as persons of interest in the murder case, prompting India to expel several Canadian diplomats in retaliation. The increasing hostilities signal a severe downturn in diplomatic ties, which were already fragile due to historical grievances and differing perspectives on the Sikh separatist movement.
Historical Context and Political Dynasties
The complex relationship between India and Canada dates back decades, with key moments such as the 1985 Air India bombing marking significant lows. The podcast outlines how Pierre Trudeau's tenure saw early tensions rise, particularly regarding the Khalistani movement, echoing back to contemporary issues faced by his son, Justin Trudeau. Political dynamics in both countries have significantly influenced bilateral relations, with Canada's changing attitudes towards Sikh extremism creating friction. The cyclical nature of these conflicts, driven by domestic agendas in Canada, continues to affect how both nations interact on multiple fronts.
Geopolitical Maneuvering and Economic Implications
The podcast discusses how Canada's foreign policy has often lagged behind that of the US, and recent tensions with India could serve Justin Trudeau's political needs as he seeks to distract from issues related to Chinese interference in Canadian politics. While trade relations between India and Canada have generally remained stable, significant underlying tensions could threaten this balance if diplomatic provocations persist. The Indo-Canadian trade has grown notably, but divergent political narratives and accusations may soon have repercussions on these economic exchanges. Experts suggest that without careful management, the escalating diplomatic spat could influence future trade negotiations and bilateral cooperation efforts.
India-Canada relations have hit an all-time low after Ottawa accused Indian diplomats of involvement in the assassination of Khalistani extremist Hardeep Singh Nijjar. India’s retaliatory expulsion of Canadian diplomats has only fueled the crisis further. With global players like the US, China, and the Five Eyes alliance involved, the stakes are high. Join host Anirban Chowdhury as he speaks with Harsh V Pant of the Observer Research Foundation and ET’s Pranab Dhal Samanta to break down the geopolitical, economic, and political factors at play.
ET Podcasts now has a new show. 7@7 is your quick, sharp sub 5 minute daily roundup of financial news from India and the world. Tune in to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Prime Music, Jio Saavn, Youtube or wherever you get your podcasts from!