Professor Edith Hall, a leading expert on ancient Greece, and comedian Dan Schreiber explore the fascinating life of Aristotle. They discuss his transformation from student to philosopher, his groundbreaking contributions to biology, and the complexities of his mentorship of Alexander the Great. Their conversation is sprinkled with humor as they dissect Aristotle's philosophical ideas on ethics and happiness, while also critiquing his views on women and societal roles. This lively dialogue reveals Aristotle's immense impact on Western thought and invites reflection on his controversial legacy.
Aristotle's diverse intellectual pursuits, from ethics to zoology, established him as a foundational figure in Western philosophy and science.
His role as Alexander the Great's tutor highlights the intricate relationship between philosophy, governance, and the ethics of leadership.
Despite his groundbreaking ideas, Aristotle's outdated views on women and slavery raise questions about his legacy as a philosopher.
Deep dives
The Life and Background of Aristotle
Aristotle was born in a town called Stagira, noted for its idyllic setting but a rather ordinary family background. His father, Nicomachus, was a physician, and Aristotle enjoyed a comfortable childhood until tragedy struck at the age of 13 when both parents died. Following this, he moved to live with his older sister, who had married a wealthy man, which provided him with further stability during his teenage years. As a young man, Aristotle exhibited a keen intellect and interest in a variety of subjects, which eventually led him to pursue formal education at Plato's Academy in Athens.
Education and Philosophical Foundations
At the age of 17, Aristotle enrolled in Plato's Academy, where he spent 20 years being immersed in philosophical teachings and various academic disciplines. While he was considered a bright student, Aristotle's interests veered towards natural science, an area that Plato largely dismissed. This divergence in focus led Aristotle to cultivate a practical approach to studying the natural world, laying the groundwork for his later contributions to logic, ethics, and empirical observation. During his time at the Academy, he gained a reputation as 'The Walking Library' and 'The Brain', which reflects his vast accumulation of knowledge and intellectual prowess.
The Tutor of Alexander the Great
After Plato's death, Aristotle faced challenges in maintaining his position within the Academy and ultimately accepted a new role offered by Philip II of Macedon to tutor his son, Alexander. Teaching Alexander required a delicate balance as Aristotle aimed to instill in him the importance of ethics, governance, and philosophy, knowing the latent potential within this ambitious young ruler. Their relationship was complex, with Aristotle's teachings influencing Alexander's later actions as a conqueror, though Aristotle himself distanced his philosophical tenets from the pursuit of power. This pivotal role solidified Aristotle’s place in history as not only a philosopher but also as an educator shaping future leaders.
Scientific Contributions and Innovations
During his time on the island of Lesbos, Aristotle made groundbreaking advancements in zoology and marine biology, categorizing and documenting various species. He was one of the first to describe environmental impacts, noting the extinction of certain species due to overfishing, a pioneering idea for his time. His empirical methods involved careful observation and analysis, setting a high standard for scientific inquiry and establishing a foundation that would endure for centuries. Despite some inaccurate beliefs about other aspects of biology, Aristotle's legacy includes a wealth of knowledge that contributed significantly to the fields of natural sciences.
Ethics, Politics, and Legacy
Aristotle's ethical philosophy, particularly articulated in works like the Nicomachean Ethics, emphasizes virtue ethics, suggesting that moral excellence and happiness are achieved through moderation in one’s actions and emotions. His philosophical framework is centered on the concept of 'eudaimonia', a state of flourishing that arises from living virtuously and fulfilling one’s potential. While he held beliefs that are now considered outdated, such as the intellectual inferiority of women and justifications for slavery, his ideas on ethics and governance have had a lasting impact on Western thought. Aristotle’s teachings gained renewed significance in the Middle Ages and continue to influence contemporary discussions on morality, politics, and philosophy.
Greg Jenner is joined in ancient Greece by Professor Edith Hall and comedian Dan Schreiber to learn all about famous philosopher Aristotle and his world changing ideas. Born a doctor’s son in the coastal settlement of Stagira, Aristotle would go on to revolutionise intellectual life in the west, writing on everything from theatre and the arts to politics, moral philosophy and zoology. After studying under Plato at his academy, Aristotle became a teacher himself, tutoring none other than a young Alexander the Great in Macedon before returning to Athens to found his own school, the Lyceum. And yet this extraordinary life came to an end in exile, after he was banished from his beloved Athens. This episode charts Aristotle’s incredible rise and fall, exploring his intellectual career and philosophical ideas alongside his friendships and romances, and asking whether despite his views on women and slavery he deserves the title of the greatest Greek philosopher.
If you’re a fan of ancient academic rivalries, bloodthirsty kings, and incredible scientific discoveries, you’ll love our episode on Aristotle.
If you want more Greek philosophers with Professor Edith, check out our episode on Pythagoras. And for more from Dan Schreiber, listen to our episode on Young Napoleon.
You’re Dead to Me is the comedy podcast that takes history seriously. Every episode, Greg Jenner brings together the best names in history and comedy to learn and laugh about the past.
Hosted by: Greg Jenner
Research by: Madeleine Bracey
Written by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow, Emma Nagouse, and Greg Jenner
Produced by: Emmie Rose Price-Goodfellow and Greg Jenner
Audio Producer: Steve Hankey
Production Coordinator: Ben Hollands
Senior Producer: Emma Nagouse
Executive Editor: James Cook
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
