The Uncommon Career Podcast: Job Search & Transformative Career Coaching

144. From Tactical to Strategic: 4 Ways to Elevate Your Interview Career Stories

Dec 30, 2025

Tired of missing out on job offers despite strong interviews? Discover how elevating your career stories from tactical to strategic can make all the difference. Learn why traditional STAR methods fall short and how to reveal your strategic thinking. Four key shifts can help you illustrate your leadership potential: think bigger by understanding organizational context, simplify complexity with frameworks, anticipate future challenges, and address hiring leaders' concerns. Transform your interviews into compelling narratives that showcase not just what you’ve done, but what you’ll achieve.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

How Apple Won Trust

Patricia Ortega describes choosing a Mac over a Dell after seeing Apple's future-focused messaging in store.
That story illustrates how showing thinking and vision builds trust beyond current features.

INSIGHT

Strategy Is The Missing STAR Element

The missing piece in many STAR stories is the strategy — the why behind actions.
Sharing your thinking converts single outcomes into repeatable, trust-building evidence of capability.

ADVICE

Name Interdependencies And Trends

Think bigger than your role by naming interdependencies and external trends that shaped your work.
Show employers you understand the organization, industry, and leadership concerns beyond day-to-day tasks.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

If your interviews usually go well but the offers keep falling just out of reach, this episode pinpoints what’s missing. Today’s conversation explores why strong qualifications and polished answers aren’t always enough—and how elevating your career stories from tactical to strategic changes how employers see your potential. We'll break down how to move beyond listing actions and results and instead communicate how you think, plan, and lead.

Using a clear, practical framework, this episode shows how strategic storytelling helps hiring leaders trust not just what you’ve done, but what you’ll do next. When employers understand your thinking, your interviews stop blending in and start influencing decisions.

You’ll learn:

✔ Why traditional STAR stories often fail to create differentiation

✔ How to reveal your strategic thinking—not just your past actions

✔ Four shifts that instantly elevate your interview responses

✔ How to show future potential, not just past performance

✔ What makes employers trust your outcomes aren’t a one-time fluke

⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯⎯
👋 WELCOME TO THE UNCOMMON CAREER!
Here's a few ways we can get to know each other:

📥 Podcast Roadmap - our best guidance for every stage of your search: https://theuncommoncareer.com/roadmap

📥 90 Days to the Right Offer: https://theuncommoncareer.com/90

🔍 Learn about our start-to-finish brand development and job search program: https://theuncommoncareer.com/approach

💬 Connect with me on LinkedIn to get targeted resources: https://www.linkedin.com/in/pmortega/

💬 Ask me anything and get featured on the podcast: https://theuncommoncareer.com/ask

📆 Ready to talk through your specific job search? Book a call here: https://theuncommoncareer.com/call

______________________

Patricia Ortega is known for teaching a strategic, emotionally intelligent approach to job searching that emphasizes clarity over activity, quality over quantity, and positioning over credentials—helping mid-career professionals rise above crowded applicant pools and land aligned roles faster.