2025 = Biggest Bank M&A Year In History? Bank Zhar Brad Rinschler on Credit, CRE, GBank, REIT Pain, and Much Much More
Feb 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Brad Rinschler, managing partner at Down Range Capital, specializes in bank stocks and shares insightful market trends. He discusses his bearish stance on the five banks that failed in 2023 and highlights the promise of small and community banks in 2025. Rinschler dives deep into G-Bank's transformation and emphasizes the potential for a historic year in bank mergers and acquisitions. The conversation also touches on the resilience of community banks amid rising interest rates and the challenges of commercial real estate lending.
The shift in investment perspectives favors community banks due to their attractive dividends and trading below book value.
Rising interest rates have negatively affected banks' earnings, exposing vulnerabilities in fixed-rate loan portfolios and capital structures.
The 2025 banking landscape is poised for record M&A activity as regulatory changes facilitate consolidations among underperforming small banks.
Deep dives
The Evolving Outlook on Banks
The perspective on banks has shifted recently, particularly favoring community banks as an appealing investment option. Many community banks are currently trading below their book values, offering attractive dividends averaging between 4% and 5%, with some reaching as high as 8%. Regulatory changes favoring mergers in the community banking sector suggest a more conducive environment for consolidation, which could enhance valuations. Overall, the expectation is for a positive trajectory for these smaller banks moving forward.
Challenges in Large Bank Investments
Investing in larger, established banks presents distinct challenges, with high valuations and complex balance sheets making it difficult to gauge the true financial health of these institutions. Many of the prominent banks, such as JP Morgan and Goldman Sachs, often do not align with the investment strategies focused on smaller community banks, primarily due to the differences in evaluation metrics and management transparency. As larger banks navigate intricate financial landscapes, the appeal for smaller, more transparent banking institutions remains strong. This strategic focus on community banks reflects a preference for clearer investments with potentially higher returns.
Impact of Interest Rate Changes
The rapid rise in interest rates significantly affected banks' earnings and asset values, particularly impacting fixed-rate loans and securities portfolios. Many banks failed to adequately hedge against these risks, leading to substantial declines in their capital bases and a decrease in market confidence. Despite banks often claiming they benefit from rising rates due to increased net interest income, the effects on their overall balance sheets have proven more detrimental than anticipated. The fallout from the fast-paced rate hikes continues to pose risks for banks, especially those with significant exposure to long-term fixed assets.
The Perfect Storm for Bank Deposits
The competition for deposits has intensified as investors flock to higher-paying Treasury yields, resulting in rapid deposit flight from community banks to more lucrative alternatives. This makes it increasingly challenging for banks to retain deposits unless they offer competitive interest rates, incentivizing potential bank failures if cash flows deteriorate further. As banks struggle with rising deposit costs, the ability to maintain liquidity becomes critical, with the threat of sudden capital outflows looming large. The combination of high deposit beta and the allure of Treasury rates creates a precarious situation for financial institutions.
G-Bank Financial Holdings: A Bright Spot
G-Bank Financial Holdings has emerged as a promising investment within the banking sector, particularly due to its unique focus on providing specialized financial services in the gaming space. The bank has successfully secured non-interest-bearing deposits through stable revenue from lottery partnerships and an innovative credit card offering designed for casino patrons. As the bank expands its non-interest deposits through technology and unique service offerings, it positions itself for substantial earnings growth. The expectation of increasing market demand for its unique financial products suggests a strong upside potential in the bank's future performance.
Navigating the M&A Landscape
Looking ahead, the outlook for mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector is robust, with predictions pointing towards 2025 being a potentially record year for small bank consolidations. Regulatory environments are becoming friendlier towards small bank mergers, creating a ripe opportunity for financial institutions struggling to achieve profitability on their own. With many small banks trading below their intrinsic value, potential acquirers, including credit unions, may capitalize on these disparities in valuation. The expectation is that a wave of mergers will reshape the banking landscape, providing attractive investment opportunities for those willing to navigate the evolving market dynamics.
Brad Rinschler, managing partner and portfolio manager at Down Range Capital, joins Jack to share his in-depth view on the many niches of publicly traded bank stocks. Rinschler explains why he was short all 5 of the banks that failed in 2023, and why he is relatively constructive on small & community banks in 2025. He also offers his bull case for the red-hot stock $GBFH, which he has been involved with for many years. Recorded on January 27, 2025.
Follow Jack Farley on Twitter https://x.com/JackFarley96
Follow Brad Rinschler on Twitter https://x.com/thebankzhar