Martin Wolf talks to Arvind Subramanian: India, the next economic superpower?
Jan 27, 2025
auto_awesome
Arvind Subramanian, former chief economic advisor to the Indian government, shares insights on India's economic ambitions. He critiques the government's investment climate, expressing concern about potential currency crises. The discussion highlights the challenges India faces in achieving high-income status by 2047 amidst declining investments and inadequate reforms. Subramanian emphasizes the importance of export-led growth and addresses the complex relationship between exchange rates and financial stability, questioning the sustainability of India's rapid growth trajectory.
India's aspiration to become an economic superpower by 2047 faces challenges from declining private investment and mismanaged currency policy.
The rise of illiberalism under Modi's government threatens democratic norms and could hinder India's global ambitions despite its demographic advantages.
Deep dives
Current Economic Challenges
India's economy has experienced a significant slowdown following a brief period of robust recovery from the pandemic. Key issues now include declining private investment and a drop in global foreign direct investment (FDI), all suggesting a waning confidence in the government's economic management. The central bank's approach to exchange rate management has created complications, as it moved towards a fixed exchange rate that is now difficult to sustain amidst shifting global conditions. The Reserve Bank of India's substantial currency defense has led to tighter monetary policy at a time when the economy needed the opposite, complicating prospects for recovery.
Structural Growth Constraints
The long-term growth potential of the Indian economy is being constrained by various structural issues that have persisted since the Modi era began. Although the government achieved some progress in improving public infrastructure and expanding social welfare programs, the anticipated growth surge has not materialized, reflected in weak manufacturing exports and insufficient private investment. The government’s focus on national champions and increasing protectionism has further inhibited competition and diminished investor confidence. Consequently, growth projections are significantly lower than historical performance, with potential per capita growth expected to linger around 3% to 4%.
Political and Global Implications
The political landscape under Narendra Modi has seen growing illiberalism and nationalistic sentiments that could hinder India's broader ambitions for global significance. While India's size ensures it will play a crucial role in global matters regardless of growth rates, the journey toward developed nation status by 2047 appears increasingly unlikely without substantial reforms. The domestic atmosphere has also shifted, with rising discontent among various communities against a backdrop of centralized governance and declining democratic norms. These factors raise questions about India's future trajectory on the world stage and its potential as a superpower while grappling with internal challenges.
India is the world’s most populous nation, and since the 1990s it has maintained almost Chinese levels of rapid economic growth. Prime Minister Narendra Modi aims to make India a high income country and, by implication, an economic superpower by 2047. But is that achievable? This week’s guest, Arvind Subramanian, is a former chief economic adviser to Modi’s government. He is sceptical that the necessary growth rate can be sustained. Instead, he tells Martin Wolf how he thinks the government has scared off the necessary business investment, and how a serious miscalculation by the country’s central bank may be about to plunge India into a currency crisis.
Martin Wolf is chief economics commentator at the Financial Times. You can find his column here