

S2E6: Contemplating US Defeat in A Modern Conflict with China
10 snips May 16, 2022
Join Anand Toprani, Nicholas Murray, and Michael Dennis, strategy and policy experts from the US Naval War College, as they tackle the unsettling prospect of an American defeat in a conflict with China. They critique traditional military wargaming, emphasizing the need to rethink defeat and learn from history. Discussion spans from logistics and technology's role in military power to the semiconductor supply chain crisis affecting U.S. manufacturing. The conversation underscores cultural attitudes toward conflict and the need for a more robust strategy in today's complex geopolitical landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Misconceptions About Great Power Conflict
- Wargaming and strategic analysis often oversimplify conflict outcomes by focusing on tactical engagements alone.
- Great power conflict traditionally involves long-term resilience beyond single battles.
The Avoidance of Defeat Discourse
- U.S. discussions often avoid the possibility of defeat, reflecting a cultural discomfort.
- Successful strategic planning requires confronting potential losses honestly and thoroughly.
American Defeat Myths Are Not Unique
- The U.S. shares common defeat myths with other nations, especially political right ideologies blaming internal betrayal.
- Recognizing these patterns aids in understanding American and global responses to defeat.