Annie Duke, author and former professional poker player, discusses the underrated importance of quitting in various aspects of life and how blind commitment to grit and stick-to-it-iveness can lead us astray. She explores misleading mental tendencies, the dangers of clinging to a certain identity, the rising costs and delays of the California High Speed Rail project, the importance of prioritizing challenges, the significance of quitting in politics, bringing decision education to every child, and the concept of quiet quitting in jobs.
Quitting is often underrated and blindly persevering can lead us down the wrong path in our careers, personal lives, and politics.
Recognizing cognitive biases like the sunk cost fallacy can help us overcome the fear of quitting and make informed decisions based on the present value and worthiness of an endeavor.
Seeking guidance from unbiased quitting coaches and establishing kill criteria can provide valuable insights and help us objectively evaluate the worthiness of our pursuits.
Deep dives
Importance of Quitting and Recognizing Worthwhile Pursuits
Annie Duke, author and former professional poker player, emphasizes the importance of quitting and recognizing when a pursuit is no longer worthwhile. She argues that quitting is often underrated and that blind commitment to perseverance can lead us down the wrong path. Duke provides examples ranging from Muhammad Ali's refusal to retire from boxing to the catastrophic consequences of the Vietnam and Iraq wars, highlighting the need to weigh the worthiness of our pursuits throughout our careers, personal lives, and politics.
The Fallacy of Grit and the Significance of Sunk Costs
Duke challenges the notion that grit is always virtuous, suggesting that it is closely linked to quitting. She explains that grit and quitting are two sides of the same decision, and the worthiness of a pursuit should be a crucial consideration. Duke delves into cognitive biases such as the sunk cost fallacy, highlighting how our focus on what we have already invested can blind us to the potential benefits of quitting and reallocating our resources. She emphasizes the need to redefine waste as a prospective problem and urges individuals to make fresh decisions based on the present value and worthiness of an endeavor.
The Role of Quitting Coaches and Kill Criteria
Duke introduces the concept of quitting coaches, highlighting the importance of seeking guidance from individuals who can offer an unbiased perspective and prioritize our long-term interests. These coaches can provide valuable insights and help us navigate our decision-making process. Additionally, Duke explains the usefulness of kill criteria, which involve setting predetermined signals or conditions that indicate when it may be prudent to quit. By establishing kill criteria in advance, individuals can more objectively evaluate the worthiness of their pursuits and make informed decisions based on predetermined thresholds.
The Benefits of Forced Quitting and the Possibility of Returning
Duke shares her personal experience of forced quitting, recounting how a health issue led her to discover and excel in the world of professional poker. This experience taught her the importance of exploring alternative opportunities and led her to use her psychology background to develop forecasting training. Duke emphasizes that quitting is not always permanent and that it can open doors to new possibilities. She highlights the value of recognizing opportunities for forced quitting and the potential for later returning to a pursuit with renewed perspective and appreciation.
The Importance of Explore and Exploit Strategies
In this podcast episode, the speaker discusses the concept of explore and exploit strategies, using the example of forager ants. The forager ants that go to a known food source, such as a watermelon, are considered the exploiters, while the ants that continue to wander and search for new food sources are the explorers. The speaker applies this concept to human decision-making and emphasizes the importance of having a balance between exploitation and exploration. In personal and professional lives, it is crucial to take calculated risks, explore new opportunities, and have a backup plan (plan B) in case something goes wrong with the current plan (plan A). The speaker also provides examples of how failure to explore and adapt can lead to negative consequences, like the downfall of Blockbuster. Overall, the main idea conveyed is that both exploit and explore strategies are essential for making optimal decisions and achieving success.
The Power of Quitting and Decision Education
The speaker highlights the importance of recognizing when to quit and the significance of decision education. Quiet quitting, which refers to staying in a job but doing as little as possible, is not considered quitting and is discouraged. The speaker encourages individuals to quit unfulfilling jobs and pursue new opportunities if they are not satisfied. Quitting is seen as a way to take control over one's life and make better decisions. The speaker also discusses the Alliance for Decision Education, a nonprofit organization co-founded by the speaker and her husband. The organization's mission is to bring decision education to every K-12 student, focusing on teaching students how to make better decisions and develop critical thinking skills. The organization collaborates with educators, researchers, and policymakers to integrate decision education into the curriculum. The podcast episode emphasizes the importance of decision-making skills in individuals' lives and the positive impact decision education can have on shaping a better society.
Quitting is massively underrated, says Annie Duke, an author, psychologist, and former professional poker player who holds a bracelet from the 2004 World Series of Poker.
Her latest book is Quit: The Power of Knowing When To Walk Away. Using examples ranging from Muhammad Ali's refusal to retire from boxing earlier in his career to the over-budget, much-delayed California high-speed rail project to catastrophic American wars in Vietnam, Afghanistan, and Iraq, she makes the case that blind commitment to grit and stick-to-it-iveness routinely leads us down the wrong path is our careers, politics, and personal lives.
She talks about misleading mental tics like the sunk-cost fallacy, the cult of identity, and the endowment effect, and how to understand and reverse them in our personal lives, our work, and our politics. She earned her Ph.D. in cognitive psychology from the University of Pennsylvania, getting her degree in 2023 after taking a 30-year break from academia. We talk about how her experience of knowing when to quit in poker—and higher education—informed her high regard for knowing when to head for the exits.
To see a Reason interview about Duke's previous book Thinking in Bets, go here.
Today's sponsor:
BetterHelp. Are you at your best? Working with a therapist can help you get closer to the best version of you—because when you feel empowered, you're more prepared to take on everything life throws at you. If you're thinking of giving therapy a try, BetterHelp is a great option. It's convenient, flexible, affordable, and entirely online. Just fill out a brief questionnaire to get matched with a licensed therapist, and switch therapists anytime for no additional charge. If you want to live a more empowered life, therapy can get you there.
