Backlash against promoting DEI led to Dr. Whitfield's suspension in education.
Racism exposed in high school with mock slave trade text chain.
Jerry Craft's book catalyst for debates on race and censorship in schools.
Deep dives
Dr. James Whitfield's Email Response to Racial Awakening
Dr. James Whitfield, a newly appointed high school principal in a Dallas suburb, crafted a heartfelt email response in the summer of 2020 following the heightened dialogues about racism triggered by events like the George Floyd murder. Whitfield's email highlighted the importance of denouncing systemic racism and the newfound support for issues of race, signaling a shift towards collective activism against racial injustices.
Dr. Whitfield Faces Backlash for Discussing Racism in Schools
Despite Dr. Whitfield's efforts to address systemic racism and promote inclusivity, backlash ensued as some individuals misconstrued his actions, associating him with critical race theory and accusing him of indoctrinating students. This controversy culminated in his placement on administrative leave and subsequent contract non-renewal, reflecting broader societal tensions around discussions of race in education.
Navea's Traumatic Experience Revealed Through a Group Chat
Navea, a high school student in a mostly white town, uncovered a harmful group chat where classmates listed black students for sale, displaying abhorrent racism. This traumatic incident, reminiscent of a modern-day slave auction, exposed the deep-seated prejudice within her community and raised questions about belonging and trust.
Jerry Craft's Book 'New Kid' Sparks Controversy
Jerry Craft, author of the graphic novel 'New Kid,' faced challenges when a parent in Texas accused his book of promoting critical race theory, leading to its temporary ban. Despite its intent to depict a 12-year-old black boy's ordinary experiences in a predominantly white school, the novel sparked debates on race and censorship in educational settings.
Impact of Book Bans on Racial Representation and Discussions
Efforts to ban books depicting diverse experiences, such as those by black authors or about historical figures like Rosa Parks, underscore broader societal divisions over race discussions. The restrictive legislation and parental objections reflect larger debates on discomfort, guilt, and censorship surrounding racial narratives in educational contexts.
President Trump is eradicating DEI from the federal government, and private companies are following his example. We return to a show we did two years ago about the turning point that led to this moment. Our Executive Producer Emanuele Berry guest-hosts and shares stories about Black people who found themselves caught in the middle of this cultural fight when the country shifted decisively away from diversity, equity, inclusion, critical race theory, and affirmative action.
Prologue: As a new high school principal, Dr. Whitfield felt moved by the national renouncement of racism he saw all around him in the wake of George Floyd’s murder. It prompted him to write a thoughtful email to parents and teachers in his district. He got lots of praise for it. Less than a year later, that same email would threaten his job. (12 minutes)
Act One: During her sophomore year in high school, Nevaeh was targeted in a secret text message chain by a handful of her peers. She’d come to learn the text chat was a mock slave trade where her photo and photos of other Black classmates were uploaded, talked about as property, and bid on. Emanuele Berry talks to Nevaeh about what these messages mean to her now as well as how she’s navigated her town’s reaction and her close friendships with kids who mostly aren’t Black. (20 minutes)
Act Two: After the murder of George Floyd, sales of books by Black authors skyrocketed. Now, there are efforts to ban many of the same books. Producer Chana Joffe-Walt talks to author Jerry Craft, who is caught up in this backlash with his graphic novel New Kid. (21 minutes)