The Rise and Fall and Rise of Communism - Dr. Sean McMeekin | #56
Nov 12, 2024
auto_awesome
In a captivating discussion, Sean McMeekin, a Bard College professor and author of several acclaimed books on Soviet history, dives deep into the origins and complex legacy of Communism. He explores the darker side of Lenin and Stalin's reign, contrasting romanticized Hollywood portrayals with historical facts. The conversation highlights the harrowing experiences of those on the Eastern Front during WWII, critiques bureaucratic systems in modern contexts, and addresses the evolution of freedom and civil liberties in contemporary society.
The podcast critiques the oversimplified portrayal of communism in media, emphasizing the violent realities often overlooked in favor of a romanticized narrative.
Sean McMeekin shares his academic journey into communism, shaped by personal interviews that reveal the harsh truths of historical and ideological complexities.
The discussion draws unsettling parallels between historical totalitarianism and modern governance responses to crises, highlighting the fragility of civil liberties.
Deep dives
Misconceptions of Communism's Historical Role
The podcast highlights the pervasive misconceptions surrounding communism's historical role in anti-fascism, often overstating its contributions while neglecting its violent nuances. It discusses how figures like Lenin and Stalin mobilized discontented societal members to commit heinous acts, distorting the popular narrative that views communists solely as early anti-fascists. The host emphasizes that many depictions in Hollywood and mainstream media simplify and misrepresent the historical context and actions of communist leaders during World War II and in the preceding years. This results in a skewed understanding, which is often celebrated among certain circles while dismissing the complexity of these historical events.
Personal Journey in Understanding Communism
The speaker shares his personal journey of academic exploration in communism, which began in adolescence and evolved into a serious research focus influenced by historical events and poignant encounters. He recounts interviewing Red Army veterans after obtaining a grant from the National Endowment for the Humanities, revealing their diverse experiences and perspectives on communism and World War II. These interviews exposed the brutal reality of war through personal narratives that contradicted simplistic ideological views, igniting a lifelong fascination with the subject. The speaker's struggle with language barriers initially hampered deeper explorations but ultimately fueled his determination to access and understand the wealth of archival resources.
The Fatalism of the Russian Character
The discussion examines the character of the Russian populace, characterized by a certain fatalism that may have been shaped by historical experiences under various autocratic regimes. This fatalism presumably predisposes individuals to endure and accept the often cruel whims of totalitarian governments without significant resistance. The speaker elaborates on how this mentality contributed to communism's rise, suggesting that Russians, conditioned by centuries of hardship, may inadvertently align with authoritative governance styles that emphasized obedience over individual agency. This philosophical exploration raises questions about broader societal compliance to oppressive regimes, not limited to Russia but applicable to contemporary governance models.
Romanticized versus Real Communism
The podcast contrasts the romanticized view of communism with its harsh realities, illustrating how many Westerners have embraced a sanitized version that forgets the system's inherent violence and oppressive nature. The speaker notes that despite the ongoing historical evidence of communism's failings, certain segments of society still romanticize its promise of equality and worker empowerment while disregarding its authoritarian implications. This discrepancy is characterized as a disconnection from historical understanding, leading some individuals to advocate for ideals that echo Marxist principles without confronting the resultant societal outcomes. The dialogue encourages listeners to recognize the ideologies' complexities and resultant historical actions rather than accepting simplified narratives.
Contemporary Echoes of Totalitarianism
The conversation addresses modern parallels to totalitarianism, especially in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic, suggesting that bureaucratic measures enacted during this period reflect authoritarian tendencies reminiscent of historical communist regimes. The speaker highlights how governmental responses categorized individuals as 'essential' or 'non-essential,' effectively stripping away civil liberties under the guise of public health. He draws attention to the alarming moralistic language used against those who resist such measures, likening it to societal ostracization seen under totalitarian regimes. This analogy serves as a cautionary reminder of the fragility of freedoms and the need for vigilance against contemporary ideological movements that could echo historical totalitarian patterns.
Today, Santiago & Josh interview Sean McMeekin, Professor of European History and Culture and Author of Stalin's War, to discuss the origins of Communism, the influence and impact of Lenin and Stalin, World War II Revisionism, and applications to modern day US politics.
#SeanMcMeekin #Communism #WorldWarII #Stalin #Lenin #Election #War #Famine #Politics
Sean McMeekin teaches courses in modern European, Russian, Soviet, and post-Soviet history at Bard College. He has also taught at Koç University in Istanbul, Yale, Bilkent in Ankara, and NYU. He is the author of Stalin’s War (2021); The Russian Revolution (2017); The Ottoman Endgame: War, Revolution, and the Making of the Modern Middle East (2015, awarded the Arthur Goodzeit Book Prize); July 1914: Countdown to War (2013, reviewed on the cover of the New York Times Sunday Book Review); The Russian Origins of the First World War (2011, winner of the Norman B. Tomlinson Jr. Book Prize); The Berlin-Baghdad Express: The Ottoman Empire and Germany’s Bid for World Power (2010, winner of the Barbara Jelavich Book Prize); History’s Greatest Heist: The Looting of Russia by the Bolsheviks (2008); The Red Millionaire (2004); and numerous articles and essays. McMeekin also reviews books regularly for the Sunday Times, The Literary Review, American Historical Review, History Today, Journal of Modern History, Slavic Review, and Journal of Cold War Studies.
Learn more about Sean McMeekin's work:
https://www.bard.edu/faculty/sean-mcmeekin
----------
Follow New Founding across Social Media:
Twitter – https://twitter.com/newfoundingorg
YouTube – https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClCvCeAC7erMbc3zvuJN2_Q
Website – https://www.newfounding.com
Find the Best People. Join our Talent Network:
https://www.newfounding.com/talent
Follow Us on Twitter:
Santiago Pliego – https://twitter.com/santspliego
Joshua Clemans – https://twitter.com/joshuaclemans
The New Founding Podcast is recorded at the New Founding HQ in Dallas, Texas, produced by Santiago Pliego & Joshua Clemans, and edited by Jared Cummings.
Subscribe to the "New Founding Podcast"
Podbean – https://newfoundingpodcast.podbean.com/
Apple Podcasts – https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/the-new-founding-podcast/id1688229934
Spotify – https://open.spotify.com/show/1lSzo1TIs7MpVlCrzqbpap
Google Podcasts - https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkLnBvZGJlYW4uY29tL25ld2ZvdW5kaW5ncG9kY2FzdC9mZWVkLnhtbA?sa=X&ved=0CAMQ4aUDahcKEwiY8sLYno7_AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQNQ
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
