Domingo Morel, "Developing Scholars: Race, Politics, and the Pursuit of Higher Education" (Oxford UP, 2023)
Nov 19, 2024
auto_awesome
In this discussion, Domingo Morel, author of "Developing Scholars," dives deep into the history of college access programs for students of color. He outlines how community activism shaped a more inclusive approach to affirmative action during the 1960s. Morel reveals how protests—sometimes violent—sustained these vital programs and emphasizes the ongoing barriers faced by marginalized students in higher education. He examines the systemic challenges of credentialism and the urgent need for equitable educational reforms to support underrepresented communities.
Domingo Morel emphasizes the importance of community-centered affirmative action programs like Talent Development in promoting equitable access to education for marginalized students.
The podcast illustrates how student protests and activism were crucial in establishing and preserving educational support programs that empower underrepresented communities against systemic inequalities.
Deep dives
The Role of Personal Experience in Education Access
The discussion highlights the impact of personal experiences on educational access for students of color. Domingo Morrell shares his journey through the Talent Development Program, which provided crucial support for students lacking adequate qualifications for college admission. This program not only offered financial assistance but also emotional and academic support, helping students navigate the transition to higher education. Morrell's successful story exemplifies how targeted programs can empower underrepresented students, ultimately allowing them to pursue their academic goals.
Historical Context and Formation of Educational Programs
The origins of the Talent Development Program are rooted in the civil rights movement, driven by activists' demands for equitable access to education for Black students and other marginalized groups. Community protests in the 1960s played a significant role in establishing and maintaining such programs, highlighting the urgent need for inclusion amidst systemic discrimination. These efforts were characterized by a push against restrictive admissions policies, emphasizing that students' potential could only be realized through supportive educational structures. The program's creation was a direct response to the historical context of exclusion that many communities faced, serving as a model for future advocacy.
The Challenges of Sustaining Educational Initiatives
The podcast outlines the challenges faced by the Talent Development Program shortly after its inception, including threats of budget cuts as the urgency of the civil rights crisis diminished. To counter these threats, students engaged in protests to demonstrate the program's impact on their lives and future generations. The involvement of both students of color and their white peers in solidarity illustrated the shared importance of educational access across demographics. This mobilization not only helped preserve the program but also reinforced the idea that sustained efforts are necessary to safeguard educational opportunities for all.
The Impact of Secondary Admissions Criteria
The introduction of secondary admissions criteria at universities created additional barriers for students previously supported by programs like Talent Development. These criteria disproportionately affected students of color and reinforced systemic inequalities in higher education access. By requiring higher GPAs and standardized test scores for entry into specific majors, institutions effectively marginalized those who were already benefiting from supportive programs. This situation illustrates the ongoing need for advocacy to address and dismantle discriminatory practices that hinder access to quality education for underrepresented communities.
Over the past fifty years, debates concerning race and college admissions have focused primarily on the policy of affirmative action at elite institutions of higher education. But a less well-known approach to affirmative action also emerged in the 1960s in response to urban unrest and Black and Latino political mobilization. The programs that emerged in response to community demands offered a more radical view of college access: admitting and supporting students who do not meet regular admissions requirements and come from families who are unable to afford college tuition, fees, and other expenses. While conventional views of affirmative action policies focus on the "identification" of high-achieving students of color to attend elite institutions of higher education, these programs represent a community-centered approach to affirmative action. This approach is based on a logic of developing scholars who can be supported at their local public institutions of higher education.
In Developing Scholars: Race, Politics, and the Pursuit of Higher Education(Oxford UP, 2023), Domingo Morel explores the history and political factors that led to the creation of college access programs for students of color in the 1960s. Through a case study of an existing community-centered affirmative action program, Talent Development, Morel shows how protest, including violent protest, has been instrumental in the maintenance of college access programs. He also reveals that in response to the college expansion efforts of the 1960s, hidden forms of restriction emerged that have significantly impacted students of color. Developing Scholars argues that the origin, history, and purpose of these programs reveal gaps in our understanding of college access expansion in the US that challenge conventional wisdom of American politics.