History Extra podcast

What causes cultures to decline and fall?

36 snips
Nov 26, 2025
In this insightful discussion, guests Luke Kemp, a researcher from Cambridge focusing on societal collapses, Islam Issa, a British-Egyptian historian specializing in Alexandria, and Caroline Dodds-Pennock, an expert on Indigenous American histories, delve into the complexities behind cultural decline. They explain how collapse involves not just immediate factors, but deep-rooted societal vulnerabilities. The conversation explores historical case studies like Ptolemaic Egypt and the Aztecs, emphasizing resilience through cultural continuity and the unexpected outcomes that can emerge from disaster.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Collapse Is About Power Structures

  • Collapse means breakdowns in power structures, not total annihilation of people or culture.
  • Societal collapse happens when state, economy, and population failures overlap but varies by case.
INSIGHT

History Informs Modern Risks

  • Studying past collapses helps us understand modern risks like climate change, inequality and warfare.
  • Different societies faced similar challenges and responded with varied successes and failures.
ANECDOTE

Cleopatra's Story Told By Roman Sources

  • Islam Issa recounts how Roman sources shaped Cleopatra's image because Octavian controlled many records.
  • He explains that Ptolemaic rulers borrowed from Rome and opened Egypt to Roman interference over centuries.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app