I think my school is getting things wrong. What should I do?
Nov 22, 2024
auto_awesome
Adam and Amy tackle the tricky issue of educational policies that clash with personal ethics. They share humorous tales about workplace rumors while engaging in light banter. With a critical lens, they discuss the repetitive cycle of failed educational policies, like the ineffective rollout of laptops. The hosts also explore what makes an effective leader in schools, debating the balance between experience and innovation. Lastly, they touch on the challenges educators face in navigating job markets and the commuting woes that come with it.
Frustration arises as educators grapple with recurring ineffective trends in education, emphasizing the need for critical evaluation of past practices.
Teachers face ethical dilemmas when institutional directives contradict their evidence-based practices, highlighting the importance of maintaining professional integrity.
Deep dives
Challenges of Education Trends
There is frustration surrounding repetitive and poorly thought-out trends in education, such as the push for project-based learning and technology integration, evidenced by recent failures like the costly investment into laptops for students in Glasgow. Such initiatives often lack a successful track record, resulting in wasted resources and ineffective policies. Understanding that these cycles of poor educational choices re-emerge every few years highlights the importance of critical evaluation of past results and the need for genuine change. The ongoing implementation of such trends without evidence-based support leaves educators feeling disillusioned, as they grapple with successfully engaging students under misguided directives.
Evaluating Educational Leadership
Education leaders play a crucial role in shaping effective policies and curriculum decisions, yet many lack the necessary experience or proven track records to justify their positions. The conversation underscores the likelihood that ineffective leaders will cycle through different roles without being held accountable for their past failures. Leaders must possess relevant experience and demonstrate competence to foster genuine improvement in teaching and learning environments. When decision-makers push ineffective methods without evidence of success, it impedes progress in schools, leaving educators to navigate a landscape of recurring poor practices.
Navigating Discrepancies in Teaching Approaches
Teachers often face challenges in aligning their evidence-based practices with institutional mandates that promote popular but ineffective methodologies. For some educators, it may be vital to adopt a strategy of compliance, implementing prescribed methods superficially while optimizing their core teaching practices behind the scenes. Engaging in discussions with leadership about specific examples and evidence for mandated approaches can help clarify expectations and may prompt reconsideration of ineffective methods. Ultimately, the dilemma emphasizes the significant ethical responsibility teachers face when the educational strategies endorsed by their institutions do not benefit their students.
The Importance of Professional Integrity
Maintaining professional integrity is crucial for educators facing conflicting directives that compromise their teaching effectiveness. Teachers must choose between conforming to prescribed approaches they know to be ineffective or risking their professional standing by innovatively steering away from such methods. In circumstances where teachers feel trapped, it may be advisable to seek positions in environments that respect their professional insight. Ultimately, fostering an educational culture that encourages open dialogue and genuine reflection can lead to a more supportive and effective teaching landscape.
Join Adam and Amy as they dive into the most common question they get, which is around what to do if your school is trying to get you to so something that professionally you don\t agree with. There are, unfortunately, no easy answers. :(
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode