Tita Rose, a dedicated Filipina immigrant eldercare worker, sheds light on the often-overlooked world of paid caregivers. She reveals her journey through the complexities of elder care and the exploitation she uncovered in a nursing home. Exploring the emotional bonds between caregivers and clients, the discussion also tackles cultural misunderstandings and advocates for workers' rights. Tita highlights the challenges of low pay and harsh working conditions, emphasizing the power of community and solidarity in the caregiving profession.
Caregivers form deep emotional connections with their patients, creating therapeutic relationships that allow for mutual sharing of experiences and vulnerabilities.
The economic challenges faced by caregivers often lead to burnout and tough career decisions, as many struggle with low wages and high demands.
Deep dives
The Continuous Need for Caregiving
Caregiving is a fundamental service required from the moment of birth and continues until death. Many caregivers, including those who work with children, the elderly, and disabled individuals, often enter the field due to personal experiences of care they lacked or witnessed growing up. Despite the emotionally rewarding aspects of caregiving, the job involves long hours of physical and emotional labor that can take a toll on caregivers' bodies and mental well-being. The relationships formed can be deeply meaningful, marked by moments of love and appreciation, yet the challenges faced often lead to exhaustion and burnout.
Financial Challenges in Caregiving Work
The financial realities for caregivers are often harsh, with many earning below the national median pay, making less than $30,000 annually. With the increasing demand for home health aides as more people choose to age at home, families face significant costs even when care is not covered by Medicare. Some caregivers, like those profiled, have chosen to leave caregiving for other jobs that promise better pay, despite their passion for the work. The economic constraints of caregiving lead to tough decisions, juggling long hours of care with the need for personal financial stability.
Intimate Connections and Shared Stories
A significant part of caregiving includes the deep conversations that develop between caregivers and those they care for, creating intimate bonds through shared experiences and vulnerabilities. Caregivers often become confidants for their patients, allowing for an exchange of stories and emotions that can profoundly affect both parties. For example, caregivers learn about their patients' regrets and fears, and sometimes reveal their own pasts as a form of connection. This mutual sharing creates a unique and sometimes therapeutic environment, enriching the caregiving experience despite the associated emotional toll.
Organizing for Worker Rights
The experiences shared highlight the importance of advocacy and worker rights within the caregiving field, particularly for those who are often underpaid and overworked. Many caregivers, like Tita Rose, have benefited from connecting with advocacy groups that educate them about their rights and entitlements. These connections can lead to significant improvements in working conditions, such as securing fair wages and adequate time off. The presence of organized support provides caregivers with the knowledge and power to change their situations, encouraging a collective push for better treatment in the industry.
Whether it's a nanny taking us to school or a home health aide helping us age in place, most of us will rely on paid caregivers at some point in our lives. For the next two episodes, we'll talk to professional caregivers about the emotional and economic reality of the intimate work they do.
In episode one, we hear from two eldercare workers: Rahn*, whose relationships with patients have helped heal emotional wounds from his childhood, and Tita Rose, a Filipina immigrant who uncovered exploitation at a nursing home. Plus Goldi, a nanny, recounts how she handled a father’s inappropriate advances and how that experience changed her approach to working for parents.
*We used first names or pseudonyms in this story.
Will you be in the Bay Area on January 31st? Anna is hosting Sketchfest, a comedy show at Club Fugazi at 7pm. Get tickets and more info here.
Podcast production by Zoe Azulay
Death, Sex & Money is now produced by Slate! To support us and our colleagues, please sign up for our membership program, Slate Plus! Members get ad-free podcasts, bonus content on lots of Slate shows, and full access to all the articles on Slate.com. Sign up today at slate.com/dsmplus.
And if you’re new to the show, welcome. We’re so glad you’re here. Find us and follow us on Instagram and you can find Anna’s newsletter at annasale.substack.com. Our new email address, where you can reach us with voice memos, pep talks, questions, critiques, is deathsexmoney@slate.com.